2. Trusts Flashcards
What are the requirements for a valid trust?
- Trustee (but a trust never fails for want of trustee)
- Beneficiary - definite and ascertainable
- Trust Property - identifiable
- Intent (present intent to form trust - words, conduct such as delivery of res to Trustee)
- Valid trust purpose
What are the rules related to a promise to form a trust?
General rule - a promise to form a trust does not form a trust, even when the res is received
Exceptions:
- If promise supported by consideration, trust is formed on receipt
- If settlor reaffirms upon receipt of the res, trust is formed
What are the rules related to a settlor trying to form a trust on future property rights?
- If settlor trying to use rights to property in a non-vested will (meaning the testator is still alive), it is illusory and not a valid trust
- But if the settlor uses rights after the will has vested (the testator has died, but before probate), this is a valid trust
What is the common law trust presumption?
Any inter-vivos (lifetime) trust is presumed to be irrevocable unless specified otherwise
What are the requirements for private trust beneficiaries?
RULE – sufficiently ascertainable
Example: “to my friends” is not ascertainable enough, “my descendants” IS enough, need not be living beneficiaries
Modern majority exception: if trust fails because of unascertainable beneficiaries, the trustee may still dispose using power of appointment
What are the traits of an honorary trust?
Common Law – honorary trusts are invalid and violate RAP
UPC – honorary trusts are valid but cannot last longer than 21 yrs and will terminate on death of the animal
Secret Trust
- Gift in will based on secret promise to hold the property in trust for third party beneficiary
- Court looks at extrinsic evidence
- Constructive trust for the beneficiary
Semi-Secret Trust
- Gift in will to devisee to hold “in trust” but fails to name beneficiary.
- Court does NOT look at extrinsic evidence
- Trustee holds for testator’s heirs
Is a pour over will valid?
- Traditional Rule – pour over will is not valid if trust is not in existence at time of execution of will
- Modern Rule – trust may be formed after execution BUT before death of testator
Trust can be modified and funded as needed during Testator’s lifetime
When is a valid contract to form a will OR refrain from revoking a will enforceable?
- Majority rule - contracts valid but if for real property, must satisfy statute of frauds
- UPC - contract to form will valid IF (a) terms are in the will; OR (b) terms of the will are in the WRITTEN contract; OR (c) the will refers to the contract (easiest)
What are the requirements of a Charitable Trust?
- Same as private trusts; BUT
- Beneficiaries must be unascertainable (not including specific charities or organizations); and
- Must have a charitable purpose (this means actually function as charitable, not masquerade as a private trust)
Special rules: does not violate RAP, can be amended using Cy Pres doctrine, enforced by state AG, settlor, or beneficiaries
What are the requirements for Cy Pres modification?
Charitable trust can be modified “as near as possible” to the intent of the trust if:
- The trust has a general charitable intent
General charitable intent determined by:
- Evidence of broader purpose that original purpose
- Direction of the trust allows for broader use
MODERN RULE - favors reformation not termination
UTC Rule - MUST imply general charitable intent and modify
What is the general rule on transfer of a trust beneficiary’s interests?
Beneficiaries - Absent limitations by trust or statute, beneficiary can freely transfer income streams or right to receive
Creditors - Absent limitations, creditors can garnish or levy on beneficiary’s interests but NOT get at the res
What are the traits of a spendthrift trust?
- Must include a spendthrift clause restricting voluntary and involuntary alienation of beneficiary’s rights
- Completely eliminates creditor’s ability to get to the income before distribution except for three exceptions:
(a) settlor’s creditors if settlor is beneficiary (self settled trust)
(b) Judgments for child, spouse, or formal spouse support
(c) Gov’t claims
What are the traits of a discretionary trust?
- Trustee is given the DISCRETION on payment of income or principal
- Beneficiary’s rights - NO right to payment (can’t enforce) unless can prove breach of trust
- Creditor’s rights
(a) CAN attach to distribution
(b) CANNOT compel distribution
(c) if Trustee notified of creditor’s attachment and decides to distribute, MUST distribute to creditor
Exceptions to limit on compeled distribution:
(a) judgment for child, spouse, or formal spouse