2 - Historical & Contemporary Views of Abnormal Behaviour Flashcards
What was in the Edwin Smith papyrus?
- detailed description of treatment of wounds & other surgical operations
- 1st record of description of brain; clearly identified as centre of mental functioning
What provides clues to the earliest treatments of diseases and behaviour disorders?
Two Egyptian papyri - the Edwin Smith papyrus and the Ebers papyrus
What was in the Ebers papyrus?
- internal medicine
- circulatory system
- reliance on incantations & magic to explain/cure diseases w/ unknown causes
Name four peoples who believed abnormal behaviour was caused by possession.
Chinese, Greeks, Hebrews, & Egyptians
How were “possessed” people treated?
Depended on whether they were thought to be possessed by a good or bad/angry spirit/god
• good: reverence & awe; believed they had supernatural powers
• bad/angry: attempted exorcism (or other means of expelling the dark force)
What did exorcism usually entail?
Magic, prayer, incantation, noise-making, & use of horrible-tasting concoctions
Who is often referred to as the father of modern medicine?
Hippocrates - Greek physician (460-377bce)
What are five ways Hippocrates’ approach was progressive or revolutionary?
- believed mental disorders had natural causes & appropriate treatments
- emphasized importance of heredity & predisposition
- acknowledged importance of environment
- gave thorough descriptions of disorders based on clinical observation
- considered dreams to be important
What were the four humours and who was associated with them?
- blood (sanguis), phlegm, bile (choler), black bile (melancholer)
- described four temperaments: sanguine, phlegmatic, choleric, & melancholic - depending which fluid was thought to be dominant in the person
- initially associated w/ Hippocrates; later w/ Galen (Roman physician)
What was one way that Hippocrates’ approach was strange and flawed?
He believed hysteria (disease w/o physical cause?) was only sufferable by women and caused by a uterus wandering about the body pining for a child (Greeks saw the body as sacred and would not cut it open - had poor knowledge of physiology)
Name three people who contributed to our understanding of depression.
Philippe Pinel - improved classification schema & examined causes
Wilhelm Griesinger - sought biological determinants
Emil Kraepelin - created classification schema upon which modern system is founded & identified manic depression as a main category
What were some of Plato’s contributions to understanding mental illness?
- said mentally disturbed individuals were not responsible for their acts & should be treated differently - ie, not be punished the same way
- made provisions for mental cases to be cared for in community
- viewed psychological phenomena as responses of whole organism reflecting internal state & appetites
- emphasized importance of individual differences in abilities
- looked at sociocultural influences in shaping thinking & behaviour
- proposed treatment in which they would be engaged in conversations comparable to psychotherapy to promote health of their souls
- still felt there was some divine causation
What were Aristotle’s contributions to psychology?
- felt that “thinking” as directed would eliminate pain & help attain pleasure
- rejected idea that mental disorders could be caused by psychological factors such as frustration & conflict; generally followed Hippocrates’ theory of disturbances in the bile
How did physicians in Alexandria, Egypt treat mental patients?
Being a Greek city, physicians there continued from Hippocrates’ work; temples to Saturn were first-rate sanatoria
• pleasant surroundings considered to be of great therapeutic value
• constant activities like parties, dances, walks in the gardens, rowing the Nile, & concerts
• used dieting, massage, hydrotherapy, gymnastics, & education
• also practiced bleeding, purging, & used mechanical restraints
What did Asclepiades contribute?
- theory that disease was caused by flow of atoms through pores
- developed treatments like massage, special diets, bathing, exercise, listening to music, & rest/quiet
What did Galen contribute?
A Roman physician (130-200 AD)
• elaborated on Hippocratic tradition
• studied anatomy of nervous system (by dissecting animals)
• divided causes into physical & mental categories
What is contrariis contrarius?
“Opposite by opposite” - eg having patients drink chilled wine while in a warm bath
Discuss the early views of mental disorders in China.
- yin/yang - sought to treat by balancing these energies/forces
- Chung Ching (sometimes called the Hippocrates of China) implicated organ pathologies as primary causes & based his theory on clinical observations; also believed that stressful psychological conditions could cause organ pathology & used both drugs & appropriate activities to restore emotional balance
- regressed to supernatural causes (like in the West), eg possession
- “Dark Ages” in China were shorter & less severe (in terms of treatment)
What survived in Islamic countries in the Middle Ages?
Scientific aspects of Greek medicine; first mental hospital was established in Baghdad in 792 AD, followed by two others (in Damascus & Aleppo), where patients received humane treatment
Who was Avicenna?
- called the “prince of physicians”
- from Persia; lived 980-1037 AD
- wrote The Canon of Medicine (possibly most widely studied medical work ever written)
- humanely & creatively treated a delusional patient who thought he was a cow and wanted to be killed
What were the Middle Ages like in Europe?
- limited inquiry into abnormal behaviour
- treatment of mentally ill characterized by ritual/superstition
- largely devoid of scientific thinking or humane treatment for mentally ill
- mental illness prevalent especially near end when institutions, social structures, & beliefs were changing
When did mass madness reach its peak?
During the 13-1400s
• Black Death was ravaging Europe, disrupting social organization
• likely that the depression, fear, & wild mysticism engendered by the events of this period was correlated
Describe two modern cases of mass hysteria.
April 1983 - affected hundreds of West Bank Palestinian girls
1990 - men in Nigeria feared their genitals had vanished; accompanying fear of death; thought it occurred supernaturally for the magical benefit of others; occurred at a time when women were more successful during economic strain
Who mainly dealt with mental illness in Europe during the Middle Ages?
The clergy - used prayer, holy water, sanctified ointments, breath/spit of priests, touching of relics, visiting holy places, & mild forms of exorcism; were generally quite kind
What was thought to be the connection between mental illness and those accused of witchcraft in the Middle Ages? What is now thought to be the connection?
- used to think mentally ill were accused of witchcraft & killed
- now think that both mentally ill and “witches” were thought to be possessed; different types of possession
Give some examples of mass madness.
- tarantism
* lycanthropy
Who was Paracelsus?
- Swiss physician (1490-1541)
- critic of superstitious beliefs about possession
- rejected demonology
- believed in astral influences (especially the moon - hence lunatic)
Who was Johann Weyer?
- German physician (1515-1588)
- carefully studied imprisonment, torture, & burning of “witches” b/c it deeply disturbed him
- published “On the Deceits of the Demons”, a point-for-point rebuttal of the Malleus Maleficarum (witch-hunting handbook, published nearly 100 years prior)
- felt that all “witches” were really sick (in mind or body)
- one of first physicians to specialize in mental disorders
- viewed as the founder of modern psychopathology
- writings banned by church; scorned by peers
What did St Vincent de Paul say?
“Mental disease is no different than bodily disease and Christianity demands of the humane and powerful to protect, and the skillful to relieve the one as well as the other.”
What were asylums like initially?
- storehouses for insane; aim was to remove them from society (those who were troublesome & incapable of caring for themselves)
- deplorable conditions (eg Bedlam); patients/inmates treated more like beasts than human beings
- often charged a fee to let people view the patients
What was the first hospital in the US devoted exclusively to mental patients, and what were their methods?
The Public Hospital in Williamsburg, Virginia (1773)
• believed that patients had to choose rationality over insanity
• “treatments” involved intimidation and were aggressive; based on scientific views of the day, aiming to restore balance to the physical body and brain
- powerful drugs
- water treatments
- blistering
- bleeding
- electric shocks
- physical restraints
What was Philippe Pinel’s experiment?
To remove chains from patients and treat them with kindness
• proposed this when he took over La Bicêtre in France in 1792
• would likely have been beheaded if it failed
• proved a great success
• created impetus for reform in the rest of Europe & America
* Pussin (Pinel’s predecessor) said he had taken humanitarian steps in his time - replacing chains w/ straitjackets for some patients & forbidding staff from beating them
Who was William Tuke?
- English Quaker
* established York Retreat
Describe the York Retreat.
- established around same time as when Pinel took over La Bicêtre (1792)
- pleasant country house
- mental patients lived, worked, & rested in a kindly, religious atmosphere
- Quakers believed in treating all people w/ kindness & acceptance
- their belief that kind acceptance would help mentally ill people sparked growth of more humane psychiatric treatment in a time when mental patients were ignored/mistreated
- continues today