1.4 rights in context Flashcards

1
Q

Define human rights

A

The basic rights and freedoms that belong to every person in the world, from birth until death. They apply regardless of where you are from, what you believe, or how you choose to live your life. They can never be taken away, although they can sometimes be restricted- for example if a person breaks the law, or the interests of national security

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

Define civil liberties

A

The rights and freedoms enjoyed by citizens which protect them from unfair treatment by the state and government. They are guarded by a constitution if present- these are called ‘civil rights’ in such countries

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

Define common law

A

Common law is set by judicial precedents when judges declare what common law should be. Sometimes called ‘judge made laws’. This is the traditional conception of how disputes should be settled and what rights people have

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

Define civil liberties vs civil rights

A

-civil liberties: the rights and freedoms that are recognised within a particular country and protect individuals from the state
-civil rights: those rights and freedoms that are protected by the government, meaning the state must take an active role in ensuring people are protected to carry out these rights

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

What should human rights be?
(hint:UFA)

A

-absolute
-universal
-fundamental

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

What is the manga carta 1215? And why is it significant

A

The first attempt to limit the power of the monarch and ensure protections against authority rule. I included the right to trial by jury and the monarch could only impose taxes with the consent of the people

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

What is the bill of rights 1689 and why is it significant?

A

-It is another set of civil liberties designed to protect people from a potential military dictatorship under William of Orange. More protections against the king
-it ensured that the monarch could not take England into a foreign war without its agreement and the people were free from ‘cruel punishments’

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

What is common law and why is it significant?

A

-judges would decide what is normal/the traditional way in which such disputes would be settled. So judges were declaring common law. Every citizen has a right to do in less it’s in law. Referred to as residual rights/negative rights
-once a judge had declared why the common law was under a particular circumstance a judicial president was set that all future cases must follow

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

What is the human rights act 1998 and why is it significant?

A

-the HRA bought into affect the European convention on human rights. Enforced by all courts in the uk so that laws passed at any level should comfort to its requirements . Acts as a check on government. Protects the rights of citizens
-traditionally the uk relied on a series of negative rights. Meaning people were allowed of do anything as long as it was not expressly forbidden in law. Meant that rights existed in the absence of law and hard to enforce. The HRA replaced this with positive rights that had to be protected by law. Binding on all public bodies

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

What is the freedom of information act 2000 and why is it significant?

A

-the labour government that came to power in the uk in 1997 decided to redress this situation though the freedom of information act in 2000. governments were too secure, it was widely condemned
-historically, citizens in the uk had no right to see information held by public bodies, whether it related personally to them or not. Since the act was passed, it has helped to improve such services as the health service, police, civil service and educational establishments, by shedding light on their activities and helping to promote reform

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

What is the equality act 2010 and why is it significant?

A

-the equality act requires that all legislation and all decision making by government must take into account formal equality for different sections of society, the act outlaws discrimination against any group, on the basis of age; gender, disability, race, sec, marriage, orientation, religion, in education, employment, healthcare, housing, law or finance
- there had been 2 parliamentary statues prior (race rejoin act 1965 and equal pay act) but they had failed to establish equality in the full sense and missed out important groups in society who have suffered discrimination e.g disabled and LGBTQ

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

What are the strengths of rights in the uk?

A

-the Uk is subject to the European convention on human rights
-the principle of equal rights is clearly established
-there is a strong common law tradition
-the judiciary has a reputation for being independent and upholding the rule of law even against the express wishes of government and parliament . The principle of equal rights is clearly established

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

What are the weaknesses of rights in the Uk?

A

-common law can be vague and disputed. It can also be set by parliamentary statutes
-parliament remains sovereign and so can ignore the ECHR or can even repeal the Human rights act
- there is increasing pressure on government, as a result of international terrorism to curtail rights in the interests of national security. The right to privacy, the right of association and expression as well as freedom from imprisonment without trial are all threatened
-what equality means is subject to interpretation and see groups coming into conflict over the enforcement of their rights such as religious groups and LGBTQ+ groups

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

What are some clear citizens responsibilities

A

-to obey the laws
-to pay taxes
-to undertake jury service when required
-responsibility to care for children

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

What are some disputed citizens responsibilities

A

-to serve in the armed forces when the country is under attack
-to vote in elections and referendums
-to respect the rights of all other citizens
-to respect the dominant values of the society

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

What is Liberty?
(hint:NCCL)

A

The national council for civil liberties renames as liberty kn 1989

17
Q

What are the aims of liberty?

A
  • the aim of challenging government measures to restrict freedoms in the UK and combat the rising threat of fascism
    -it’s objectives are to fight to protect and uphold civil rights and liberties across the UK and to develop a wider ‘rights culture’ across society
18
Q

What methods do liberty use and some examples?

A
  • it carries out research and investigations into rights abuses and restrictions and seeks to spread awareness through media campaigning (both mainstream traditional media and social media)
    -liberty also support and bring legal challenges against rights abuses, e.g the recent legal challenge on lockdown restrictions, as well as providing legal advice and support to cases of discrimination against gay rights, women’s rights and disability rights
  • liberty will also work with the government and parliament to advise on legislation and ensures it complies with the HRA
  • liberty also regularly organises petitions and offers pledges. It also organises protests and public demonstrations to raise awareness and demonstrate public support for their case
19
Q

What successes has liberty had?

A
  • in 2020, liberty used legal actions by bringing a case under the HRA to successfully pressure Bournemouth, Christ church and Poole council into removing parts of the public spaces protections order that had been used to criminalise rough sleepers and beggars
    -in 2020, liberty won a court of appeal ruling against the legal framework used by south Wales police when using facial recognition technology
    -in 2017, liberty brought a successful legal challenge to the Supreme Court against a loophole in the equality act which had allowed employees not to provide equal spousal provisions for same sec couples (the Supreme Court ruled the loophole was unlawful)
20
Q

What failures have liberty had?

A

-liberty has failed, so far, in its attempts to ban the use of facial recognition across the Uk
-despite organising petitions and campaigns against lockdown restrictions in 2020-2021, the government continued to impose such restrictions on people freedoms in the name of public health
-in October 2018 the court of appeal rejected an application by liberty to bring a legal case that would have prevented a no-deal Brett from the uk

21
Q

Why is liberty successful?

A
  • it is a NFP organisation that operates like a think tank, and a membership association
    -that, and the fact it is well established, gives it a large membership base which can call on organising campaigns and demonstrations, whilst also employing legal expertise and experience to bring legal challenges to court
  • since 2000 it has been able to use the human rights act as well as the Eu law to bring legal challenges in Uk law
  • from 2003-2006 it also benefited from a charismatic leader, shami chakrabarti
22
Q

When was amnesty international founded?

A
  • founded in London in 1861 by an English barrister, Peter benenson, who claimed he was inspired by an account of two Portuguese students who had been sentenced to 7 years in prison for drinking a toast to liberty
23
Q

What are the objectives of amnesty?

A

Amnesty international operates as a global campaign group or NGO, that aims to protest people wherever they belive justice, freedom, truth and liberty have been denied. In addition to exposing and ending abuses, they claim to educate society and mobilise the public to create a safer society

24
Q

What methods did amnesty traditionally use?

A

A letter writing campaign- local branches and smaller groups are tasked with writing to an ‘at risk individual’ to show support as well as writing letters to the government concerned or to other governments in the hope that they will pressurise the offending government into taking action

25
Q

What methods do amnesty use nowadays?

A
  • today, email and Twitter are also used, such as the twitter handle #freeNazanin to pressurise the Iranian government into releasing her.
  • amnesty will also give advice and produce proforma letters and emails for people to fill in themselves to add their voice
  • they also organise petitions, public demonstrations, and vigils to raise awareness and put pressure on governments
  • they also carry out extensive research and publicise reports to highlight issues and edicate
26
Q

What successes have amnesty had?

A
  • the campaign ‘write for rights’ has seen a number of people from prison or had their rights restored following pressure from amnesty, including the release of Yesenia Armenia (Mexico June 2016) who had been jailed on the basis of confession extracted after 15 hours of torture. The release of Fred Bain’s and Yves Makwambala (Congo, August 2016) who had been detained because of their pro democracy work
  • following the majority oil spills in Nigeria in 2008 and 2009, amnesty campaigned for compensation for the 15,600 farmers and villagers who were directly impacted by the spill
  • in 2013 amnesty used satellites to capture images of human rights abuses in North Korea, Sudan and Syria
    Played a role in:
  • the release of Teodora del Camden Vasquez
  • 8000 prisoners of conscience were released in Myanmar
  • India decriminalised same sex marriage
  • the government of Malaysia and the state of Washington accounted plans to abolish the death penalty
27
Q

What failures have amnesty faced?

A
  • despite arranging 38,000 members in an online actions and repeated called for the international community to do something, china confineues to detain Muslim groups living in Chinese territory
  • a number of international government have publicly criticised amnesty for one sided reporting and failure to recognise security threats, making it harder to persuade these governments to take the desired actions
  • amnesty has failed in its aim to persuade the Vatican to remove its objections to abortion
28
Q

Why is it successful?

A

Amnesty international is successful due to its large membership base (7mil) and close relationship with other international organisations and governments. Its role in co-ordinating targeted efforts helps facilitate those who wish to fight for human rights in a way that is more likely to achieve success

29
Q

Why are rights restricted?

A
  • the Uk parliament has the power to ‘derogate’ from certain articles in the ECHR when passing law during a state of emergency or time of war
  • the labour government of Tony Blair derogated from Article 5 in the passing of the anti terrorism crime and security act 2001, which included the power to detain foreign nationals who were suspected international terrorists because they believed they represented a threat to the UK
  • there are 4 exceptions: the Uk parliament cannot derogate from articles 2,3,4,7 as these are considered absoloute. All other rights within the HRA can all be compromised in times of crises, provided it is proportionate and lawful as seen in the coronavirus act 2020, which restricted article 5 to protect public health
30
Q

Why are their clashes of rights (individual versus collective bodies)?

A
  • it is by no means clear that rights belong only to individuals, as they are also claimed by collective bodies ranging from trade unions to religious groups e. Asher’s vs Lee 2018: decided by the Supreme Court that a Belfast bakery run by Christian’s did not have to make a cake with the message ‘support gay marriage’ on it. Under Article 10 the court ruled that freedom of expression includes the right not to express an opinion that one does not hold
31
Q

What is individual versus collective rights of the state?

A
  • the biggest conflict arises between individual rights and the collective rights expressed by the state such as national security. Public health and keeping the public safe. Individual rights have come into conflict with the priorities of government in 4 ways:
    •sentencing laws
    •treatment of prisoners
    •terrorism
    •right to privacy and family life vs the need to protect others