14. Methods of combating antibiotic resistance Flashcards
What does antibiotic resistance drive?
- The emergence and re-emergence of certain infectious diseases.
- Particularly nosocomial infections
What needs to be remembered about multi-drug resistance?
- It is still relatively rare.
- It is increasing and an issue.
- MDR infections are focused around certain population groups that have lots of contact with healthcare settings and frequent courses of antibiotics.
Why does being in lots of contact with healthcare increase the risk of MDR Infections?
- Antibiotic use selects for resistance.
- Being around healthcare makes it more likely to pick up a resistant bacteria as they are mostly in other sick people
What is the biggest worry regard antibiotic resistance?
- Increasing rates of resistance in community infections
- The rates of this differ from country to country.
- Low and middle income countries have more of this due to unregulated antibiotic use.
What kinds of resistant bacteria are the biggest worry?
- ESBL producing gram-negative bacteria.
- This normal confers 3rd generation cephalosporin resistance.
- They also can have resistance to fluoroquinolone and aminoglycosides.
- This means these bacteria are resistant to the 3 main classes of antibiotics we use.
Where else can multi-drug resistance develop?
- In veterinary isolates
What do the implications of antibiotic resistance depend on?
The antibiotic access in that country.
What resistance is threatening for countries with limited access to antibiotics?
- Resistance to basic 1st line antibiotics.
- This is because those are the only antibiotics they have access to.
- These countries tend to have worse sanitation, increasing community transmission and unregulated use of antibiotics
- Infectious diseases are more common and general health is worse leading to more antibiotic use
What resistance is threatening for countries with plenty of access to antibiotics?
- There needs to be more resistance to cause a problem as there are other treatment options.
- so MDR tends to be the issue
What happens if we don’t do anything about antimicrobials resistance?
- Lower and middle income countries will see the effects first and worst.
- There will then be knock-on effects on everyone else.
What can we do the reduce the rise of resistance?
- Reduce inappropriate prescription of antibiotics.
- Inhibition of resistance proteins
- Inhibition of mutation or horizontal gene transfer.
- Better infection control
- New antimicrobials
- Alternatives to antimicrobials
Why is reducing antibiotic prescription difficult?
- Antibiotics save lives and they need to be prescribed for people who need them.
- You need to give the right antibiotic for the right infection at the right time for the right patient.
- You need to treat patients now while retaining the ability to treat future patients.
- Inappropriate prescription is the problem.
What long-term effects does antibiotic use have on resistant infections?
- If you take an antibiotic it can take up to a year before your risk of developing a resistant infection does back to baseline
- This is due to the reduced competition from the microbiome that the antibiotics have killed.
- You are also more likely to pick up resistant bacteria from the environment that can go on to cause a resistant infection.
What is the driving force of antibiotic resistance?
Antibiotic use
What types of resistance show up in countries with limited antibiotic access?
- They have more resistance to the antibiotics they can access.
- This is because they are used more as they are the only option.
- These countries rely on these limited antibiotics so resistance causes lots of issues.
What happens in countries that use lots of antibiotics?
They get lots of resistance
What tends of resistance show in countries with plenty of antibiotic access?
- They have less resistance to those antibiotics
- This is due to being able to change which antibiotics are used to treat the resistant infection.
- These mean no antibiotic is used enough to drive resistance.
What factors are associated with decreasing resistance?
- High governance index
- High health expenditure
- Better infrastructure
Why doesn’t usage seem to have a statistically significant effect on antibiotic resistance levels?
- It could be due to different patterns of use in the past
- The measure were based on just one day.
- However, it does agree with some farm-based studies that usage isn’t hugely related to resistance levels.
What surprising factor is associated with increasing resistance levels?
- High education levels
- With more educated people you would expect more rational use of antibiotics.
- However this is not the case
- They have fewer children so they are more precious. this leads to demand for antibiotics in children when they are not needed.
- Undergo global travel which increases the chance of transmission.
Is climate change associated with resistance?
- Vaguely but due to its complexity its is hard to quantify.
- But climate change does drive other factors that can drive infections and resistance.
Does reducing antibiotic use always reduce resistance?
No it can depend on the mechanism of resistance and the fitness cost.
What happened to resistance to sulphamethoxazole when use stopped?
- It was used to treat UTIs
- They stopped using it due to high resistance in E coli.
- They stopped using it for 8 years yet resistance increased.
- This shows that just reducing the use of the antibiotic doesn’t always cause resistance to drop.
What types of resistance does decreased use of the antibiotic cause decreased resistance?
- Generally mutation mediated resistance.
- Especially to fluoroquinolones
- This is being seen in the reduce use of fluoroquinolones in urinary E coli infection.
What types of resistance does decreased use of the antibiotic not effect the resistance levels?
Normally plasmid-mediated resistance or cases of altered metabolism
Why does resistance not decrease in all cases of decreased use?
- Fitness cost
- Virulence or resistance mechanism
- Co-selection using another Antimicrobial
How does fitness affect levels of antibiotic resistance?
- When you stop using an antibiotic, you want a fight between the susceptible and resistant bacteria. You want the susceptible ones to win.
- Resistance tends to come with a fitness cost reducing the growth rate.
- So, if you are not selecting the resistant strain, the susceptible ones will out-compete them.