1.4 Government Intervention Flashcards

1
Q

How is indirect tax used by the government?

A
  • indirect tax is a method a government can intervene in order to correct market failure caused by negative externalities from production
  • tax brings the new equilibrium in line with social optimum equilibrium
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

What is indirect tax?

A
  • tax on expenditure
  • it is paid by the producer to inland revenue
  • however the producer can pass on the burden of tax to the customer + does to varying degrees
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

What factors affect the price of goods with indirect tax?

A

Depends on:
- PED
- size of tax

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

Impact of indirect tax?

A
  • increases costs of production to the supplier
  • so the supply curve makes a parallel shift to the left
  • tax is initially paid by producer - but they may pass on the burden to customers
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

Advantages of indirect tax?

A
  • ‘polluter pays’ - principle of the producer responsible for negative externality pays
  • the tax can adjust according to size of the problem ( external costs)
  • the government could use the tax revenue to reduce negative externalities by investing in cleaner methods or offering subsidies in e.g. public transport, renewable energy, sugar free drinks
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

Disadvantages of indirect tax?

A
  • hard to measure external costs in some case -> difficult to put a monetary value on it
  • sometimes hard to trace the origins of atmospheric pollution - which firms are responsible?
  • other things being equal an indirect tax makes the distribution of income less equal - a specific or lump sum direct tax will take a greater proportion of a lower revenue (e.g. smaller firms)
  • higher taxes imposed by the government may discourage investment by firms or make Uk firms less competitive in the global market -> this suggests global issues of negative externalities + climate change need global solutions
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

What affect will indirect tax have on an inelastic PED?

A
  • IF PED is inelastic, demand (MSB=MPB) curve has a steep gradient, the tax will not influence the quantity significantly
  • e.g. litres of petrol consumed
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

Unintended consequences of indirect tax?

A
  • higher taxes may lead to smuggling from abroad
  • people may try and find ways around taxes
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

What is minimum price?

A
  • price floor (lowest price)
  • it is implemented because the equilibrium price is too low (implies existence of negative externalities)
  • therefore, the minimum price is set above the equilibrium
    -e.g. price of alcohol
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

How is minimum price used?

A

this can be used to make a product more expensive due to it being above the market price -> discourage demand

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

Disadvantages of minimum price?

A
  • could cause excess supply (disequilibrium)
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

What is the impact of minimum price dependent on?

A

depends of the PED/PES of a good or service
- if PED/PES is elastic, the percentage change in quantity demanded + supplied is high so bigger excess supply - but effective in reducing quantity demanded if that is the aim e.g. alcohol
- if PED is inelastic, % change in quantity demanded + supply is smaller

Also depends on how high minimum price is set above the market clearing price

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

What is maximum price?

A
  • ceiling price
  • it is used when the equilibrium price is thought to be too high + so it is set below the equilibrium price
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

Examples of maximum price

A
  • highest rent a landlord can charge for housing - however could lead to homelessness if prices are too high
  • maximum wage - the highest wage an employer can be paid
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

How is maximum price used?

A
  • used to make goods more affordable
  • price ceiling causes an excess in demand
  • this is solved through rationing -e.g. queues
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

Disadvantages of maximum price?

A
  • could lead to a shortage or worse government failure - e.g. housing shortage if housing becomes too affordable
  • a secondary (black) market may emerge - undeclared transactions would reduce tax revenue
  • excess demand can make the allocation of resources worse + can be a source of government failure
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

What is a subsidy?

A
  • a payment by the government to suppliers that reduce their costs of production + encourages them to increase output
  • this encourages firms to produce more
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

What are subsidies applicable for?

A

Goods with external benefits

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

Subsidy examples?

A
  • renewable energy
  • public transport
  • biofuels
20
Q

Affect of subsidy on graph?

A
  • subsidy lowers the cost of production + increases supply -> causes the supply curve to shift to the right + lower equilibrium price
  • this creates an equilibrium at the socially optimum output
  • this helps to correct the misallocation of resources as there is a net welfare gain from being at the socially optimum
21
Q

Why are subsidies used?

A
  • used to encourage the use of merit goods
  • e.g. health, education, childcare
22
Q

Disadvantages of subsidies to government?

A

Costs to the government:
- opportunity cost - reduction in spending on other areas e.g. welfare services
- increase tax which reduce incentives + distort the market
- increase borrowing which is already high -> budget deficit = the amount a government borrows in a year

23
Q

Disadvantages of subsidies to producers?

A
  • if a producer becomes reliant on subsidies it can lead to inefficiency - whereas without a subsidy the firm has an incentive to make profit + minimise average costs - productively efficient
24
Q

Examples of state provisions

A
  • NHS
  • state schools
  • prisons
  • roads
25
Q

What are state provisions?

A
  • the state pays for the good or service which is then free at the point of use to the recipient
26
Q

Why does the market fail in providing merit goods? (Under consumption)

A
  • if the market provided education/health these goods would be under consumed (positive externality diagram)
  • this is because some individuals would not be able to afford it
  • individuals do not take into account external benefits + so they underestimate the true value of the benefits of health + education
27
Q

Why does the market fail in providing merit goods (maximising profit)

A
  • private companies aim to maximise profits - may lead to exploitation (asymmetric information) as medical practitioners know more than patients so may offer unnecessary treatments
  • monopolies - high economies of scale available - e.g. buying all surgical equipment
  • if there is a monopoly, one major producer of healthcare may be less incentivised to provide an efficient service + quality of provision may fall
28
Q

Why does the market fail to provide healthcare?

A
  • the demand is uncertain - individuals do not know when they are going to fall ill or require healthcare
  • so private healthcare can be provided through health insurance
29
Q

Why is the demand for healthcare increasing?

A
  • ageing + increasing population - average age of population increasing
  • higher expectations/increased awareness with self diagnosis
  • improved medical research
  • obesity levels increasing
30
Q

How do trade-able pollution permits works?

A
  • polluters can bid for a permit that allows them to create a fixed amount of pollution
  • these permits can be resold (if production becomes cleaner) - firms have an incentive to reduce carbon emissions so they can make cost savings from selling permits
  • government can gradually reduce the number of pollution permits available so that total pollution emissions can be controlled
31
Q

Impact of pollution permits?

A
  • gradually total amount of pollution allowed can be reduced
  • as the stringency of pollution limit tightens, the value of permit may rise
  • supply shifts to the left, equilibrium price rises
  • they will be more valuable to companies that can bring down pollution levels (higher cost savings)
32
Q

Advantages of pollution permits?

A
  • give firms/organisations an incentive to reduce pollution
  • assuming they reduce pollution below the agreed limit they can sell off the permit to other firms or to the government
  • better than regulations as firms aren’t just encouraged to lower pollution below limit but also to continue lowering pollution as there is an award
33
Q

Disadvantages of pollution permits?

A
  • high administrative costs associated with monitoring pollution emissions - particularly if number of firms involved is large
  • relies on the fact that external factors can be measured
  • larger firms will be able to afford permits more than smaller firms + so pollution may not fall as large firms buy permits instead of investing in cleaner energy
  • permit may act as a barrier to entry into the market leading to an monopoly
  • most counties aren’t part of the emissions trading scheme e.g China - little chance of reducing global emissions
  • higher costs for firms in countries that adopt these permit - reduces competitions internationally - leading to closure of firms
34
Q

The effectiveness of tradeable permits depends on:

A
  • the negative externalities being measurable
  • the permits being expensive enough to give producers the incentive to lower pollution
  • ideally the issue of policies to correct environmental damage is resolved by a global solution as it is a global issue
  • issue of pollution may be tackled by a combination of policies e.g. tax, regulations, pollution permits
35
Q

What is information provision?

A
  • aim is to address market failure caused by information gaps
  • the idea is with more information economic agents will make better, informed decisions (consumers and producers) - better resource allocation
36
Q

Evaluation of information provision?

A
  • necessary but not always sufficient enough as a method of government intervention
  • needs to be reinforced by regulation e.g. smoking is banned in public places, advertising of smoking is banned
37
Q

What does information provisions rely on?

A
  • quality of information + reliability
  • how easily it is understood by people e.g. traffic lights is eye catching
  • some information can sometimes vary e.g. healthy foods, recommended alcohol intake, impact of vaping etc
38
Q

Examples of information provisions?

A
  • to encourage healthy goods + services e.g. fruit + veg, exercise
  • to discourage the production of+ consumption of unhealthy goods + services e.g. tobacco - health warnings on cigarette boxes, traffic light system of nutritional content of food
  • benefits of saving for pensions (a merit good)
  • drink driving
39
Q

What are regulations?

A

Laws/ rules that individuals/firms have to adhere to

40
Q

What are the aims of regulations?

A
  • aiming to reduce/ eliminate negative externalities and/or promote positive externalities e.g. attending school is compulsory
  • e.g. laws on atmospheric pollution, noise pollution etc.
41
Q

What happens if regulations are broken?

A

Firm/individual are fined

42
Q

What is the impact of regulations on supply + demand?

A
  • regulations on businesses may cause costs to increase (dbs checks, health and safety regulations)+ shift the supply curve to the left
  • regulations can open new opportunities to businesses -> e.g. businesses who supply safety equipment, demand for products may shift o right
  • PPE equipment for covid - high potential for profit as PED is inelastic (necessity)
43
Q

Advantages of regulations

A
  • individual circumstances can be analysed, and appropriate action taken
  • easily understood by firms - not likely to lead to disputes when firms break limits
  • as long as it can easily assessed whether the regulation has been broken or not
44
Q

Disadvantages of regulations

A
  • inspectors need to be employed at a cost - e.g. traffic wardens or speed cameras
  • investigations are often expensive, time consuming + only deal with a fraction of the cases
  • external costs need to be measurable e.g. pollution
  • may not be much of a deterrent - so fine needs to be high enough to alter behaviour
  • the fine has a greater impact on people of low incomes so perhaps fines should be mean tested
  • unintended consequences - comes from the idea that human beings will do what they can to get around a law. E.g. motorists speed up + then slow down at cameras
45
Q

Disadvantages of regulations (businesses/firms)

A
  • the fines need to be greater than the cost of altering the production - so firms have an incentive to reduce external costs + not just continue and pay the fine
  • regulations can only be used when the actions are easily measured
  • best use with a range of policies e.g. indirect tax, subsidies