10: Fundamental Rights and Freedoms Flashcards
How did fundamental rights and freedoms develop in the UK?
Magna Carta (1215): First attempt at protecting freedom of movement and curb Crown. Some rights included were:
- Free movement of Church without government interference
- Owning and inheriting property without excessive taxes
- Proportional fines for offenses
English Bill of Rights (1689): Foundation of Constitutional Monarchy relying on separation of powers
- Limit powers of Crown
- Enhance democratic elections
- Bolster freedom of speech
- Protection of individual rights
- Emphasized State’s power to punish
- Emphasized State’s power to regulate an army
How did fundamental rights and freedoms develop in the US?
US Constitution (1787), American Bill of Rights (1791):
Pushed for the freedom of
- Religion
- Press
- Speech
- Assembly
- From excessive fines, forfeitures, and double jeopardy
- Right to bear arms
- Right to due process
- With this first constitution, the main task of the government was to safeguard these rights
- The rights in the US Constitution are mainly negative: No references to health, religion etc.
How did the American Bill of Rights and French Declaration of the Rights of Man and the Citizen differ?
American: More wordy and philosophical, as Americans had already achieved independence and enjoyed individual rights when the Bill was applied
French: More pragmatic and suited for immediate application as the French had yet to construct a framework of freedom and rights
How did fundamental rights and freedoms develop in France?
French Declaration of the Rights of Man and the Citizen (1789):
Right to:
- Liberty
- Property
- Resistance of oppression
To be able to transition from a feudal system to a market-based system:
- Need to protect property
- Need for a unified commercial code
Also accounted for a:
- Singular criminal code
- Singular civil code
- Harm principle is very applicable in this bill where one’s liberty could be limited if it violated someone else’s
- Thus in theory, the law could only stop what was harmful to society
How did the French constitutional model circulate?
- The French model rapidly circulated
- Other countries approved Constitutions that were less democratic, but emphasized protection of rights
1848: Official French constitution
1848: Italian bill of rights (least effective at protecting rights)
1849: German bill of rights
How did the shift from liberal to democratic constitutionalism affect fundamental rights and freedoms?
The Weimar Constitution (1919) was at the heart of the shift:
- Focused on individual rights
- State was entrusted with the pursuit of social goals
For Italy, the new Constitution (1948) came into effect post-WW2 and the Fascist Regime
What is the definition of
- Positive liberty
- Negative liberty
- Negative freedom?
- Positive liberty: Capacity to act on free will
- Negative liberty: Freedom from external restraints on one’s actions
- Negative freedoms: Prevent inference and interventions from the State
What are first generation rights?
- Also called negative freedoms
- Embodied in the flexible constitutions of the liberal state
- Civil rights: Focus on sphere of personal freedom, protecting each man’s integrity
- Political rights: Protection of social sphere, and through that, individuals
What are second generation rights?
- Pertain more to positive rights
- Found mostly in the rigid constitutions of the democratic state
- Social rights: May only exist after the State removes any obstacles to social inequality
- Economic rights
e.g. Italian Constitution: Provides for rights to private and social assistance; unemployment and disability privileges
What are third generation rights?
- Developed in the 70s
- Reflect the idea that rights are not abstract and the list of rights which need to be protected can evolve over time
- Rights of private nature
- Collective rights
e.g. Portuguese Constitution: Provides for rights regarding the use of data processing
What are fourth generation rights?
- Intergenerational
- Developed in the 90s
- Promote solidarity in the use of resources to protect the needs of generations to come
Includes:
- Right of sustainable development
- Rights concerning new biotechnology research
e.g. Argentinian Constitution: Right of everyone to enjoy a balanced environment fit for human development without endangering the needs of generations to come
What are the 5 types of basic rights?
- Individual rights
- Rights of the public sphere
- Social rights
- Economic rights
- Political rights
What are individual rights?
- Instruments to protect the individual
Rights to:
- Personal freedom
- Personal domicile
- Freedom of correspondence and information
- Freedom of movement, residence, and expatriation
What are rights of the public sphere?
- Freedoms that include those that allow individuals to freely take part in civil society and the political arena
Rights to:
- Freedom of assembly
- Freedom of association
- Freedom of religion and creed
- Freedom of expression
What are social rights?
- Provide a foundation for the state to intervene in the social sector and to limit all economic and social obstacles in achieving freedom and equality
Rights to:
- Education
- Healthcare
- Welfare
- Housing