1. The Criminal Justice System Flashcards
What is the court heirarchy
Hight court Supreme Court (appeal) supreme court (trial) county court -koori court magistrate's court -children's court -coroner's court -koori court, sentencing
fairness
fairness involves impartial treatment surounding processes and procedures for all people under the law without fear or favour
fairness factors
- equal opportunity to hear information
- impartial judge/jury
- appropriate sentence
fairness words
- unbiased
- impartial
- consistent
- known
access
access involves the provision of a range of resources and institutions to settle disputes within the legal system
access factors
- dispute resolution bodies and methods
- legal personnel
- legal information
access words
- locate
- understand
- opportunity
equality
equality involves the provision of equal legal opportunitie and equal treatments for all citizens under the law
equality factors
no disadvantage because of characteristics or circumstances
legal system
a legal system is made up of a set of rules, procedures and bodies that make up and enorce laws
-they aim to achieve social cohesion and help everyone live together harmoniously
the australian constitution
- came into effect jan 1 1901
- commonwealth of australia constitution act 1900 (uk)
- establishes the framework for our parliament and its law-making powers
constitutional monarchy
a constitutional monarchy is a system of government in which a monarch is the head of state
statute law
law made by the parliaments
-debate and pass laws for the peace, order and good government of the community
statute
a law passed by a state parliament or the commonwealth
bill
a proposed law which is debated and passed by a majority of members in both houses of parliament
common law
law made by judges through decisions made in cases
criminal law
an area or body that protects the community by establishing and defining what laws are
crime
an act or omission that: -breaks an existing law -is harmful to an individual or society as a whole -is punishable by law crimes act 1958
the rule of law
the principle that everyone in society is bound in law and must obey the law, and that laws must be clera so that people want to obey them
the rule of law upheld by
- clear and accessibility of laws
- courts and judges must be independent
- the law being equally applied to everybody
- presumption of innocence
purposes of the criminal justice system
- deciding whether an accused is guilty of an offence
- imposing a sanction
reason for lack of unified criminal justice system
power to make laws about crime is left to the state, not federal parliament
jago statement
the right to a fair trial is not limited to just the trial itself
dietrich statement
a lack of fair legal representation when defending an indictable offence may result in an unfair trial
summary offences
- minor criminal offences that are generally heard in the Magistrate’s court
- summary offences act 1966 (vic)
indictable offences
serious criminal offences heard by a judge in the county or supreme courts of victoria
-generally, crimes act 1958 (vic)
indictable offences heard summarily
serious offences that can be heard and determined as a summary offence if the court and accused agree
burden of proof
the responsibility of a party to prove a case
-in a criminal case, bop is on the prosecution
standard of proof
the extent to which a case must be proved in a court
-in a criminal case, sop is beyond a reasonable doubt
the presumption of innocence
- the right of a person accused of a crime to be presumed not guilty until proven otherwise
- charter of human rights and responsibilities (section 25)
how is the presumption of innocence maintained?
- hight sop
- imposing bop on the prosecution
- bail
bail
the release of an accused person from custody on the condition that they will attend a court hearing to answer the charges
charter of human rights and responsibilities act
designed to ensure that any statue passed by the Victorian parliament is compatible with the human rights set out by the charter
-section 23 to 27 are rights available in criminal proceedings
statutory rights for an accused
- the right to be tried without unreasonable delay (section 21(5) hrc)
- the right to a fair hearing (24 (1) hrc)
- the right to a trial by jury (80 of aus constitution and statute law)
the right to a fair hearing
- competent, independent, impartial court must decide on proceedings or charge
- hearing must be fair and public
The victorian charter act 2006 (vic)
aims to recognise the impact of crime on victims, to recognise that victims should be offered a certain level of information during the court process and to reduce the likelihood of secondary victimisation
the right to give evidence as a vulnerable witness
-generally children, people with cognitive impairements, and victims of sexual abuse and domestic violence
vulnerable witness protections
- witnesses may give evidence from a place other than the courtroom
- screens may be used to remove the accused from the witness’ direct line of sight
- a support person may be used
- legal practitioners may be required to dress more casually or remain seated during questioning
the right to be informed about proceedings
-the victim’s charter requires an investigatory agency to inform a victim, at reasonable intervals, about the progress of an investigation into a criminal offence
the vla
the vla is a government agency that provides free legal advice to the community and low or no-cost legal representation to those who cannot afford it
the vla’s most critical role
to provide legal aid to accused people
vla key objectives
- legal aid act 1978
- provide legal iad in th emost effective, efficient and economic manner
- manage its resources to make legal aid available at a reasonable cost to the community
vla methods of assistance
- free legal aid (available to everybody)
- free legal advice (focused on people who need it the most)
- free duty lawyer services (fact sheets = everybody, advice = people who pass the income test, representation = income test, vla priority and/or serious charge)
- grants (pass the means tes)
the income test
- pass if they can produce a current Centrelink benefit card or prisoner concession card
- for people who need legal advice from a duty lawyer on a particular day
the means test
- sets thresholds for an applicant’s income and assets as well as their expenses and legal costs
- for people seeking grants of legal assistance during the trial process
the merits test
a threshold test which must be satisfied in most Commonwealth law matters
who does the vla prioritise
people who
- are disabled
- are homeless
- cannot speak English
- are Indigenous Australians
common vla criticisms
- not enough funding to meet demands
- a large part of the community is ineligible
clcs
clcs are independent organisations that provide free legal services, including advice, information and representation to people who cannot access other legal services
generalist clcs
provide broad legal services to people in a particular geographical area
specialist clcs
focus on a particular group of people or area of law
role of clcs
- provide people with legal information, advice and minor assistance
- also help victims of crime and their families
clc types of assistance
- basic legal information
- initial legal advice
- duty lawyer assistance
- legal casework
clc eligibility criteria (generally)
- type of legal matter
- whether other assistance is available
- whether the person has a good chance of success
- whether the accused can manage the case without assistance
committal process purpose
- criminal procedure act 2009
- determine whether evidence is of sufficient weight to support a conviction by a jury at a trial
- determine how the accused plans on pleading
committal proceedings strengths
- saves time and money
- can assist the accused in deciding on a plea
- supports presumption of innocence
- prosecution can drop charges
committal proceedings weaknesses
- complicated process, especially without representation
- can add to the delay
- contribute stress and trauma for the accused/victims
vlrc recommended reforms for committal proceedings
- case management systems should be used between courts
- test for committal should be abolished
committal proceedings strengths
- upholds the presumption of innocence
- save time and resources of higher courts
- allows the accused to be informed of the prosecution’s case against them
committal proceedings weaknesses
- complicated
- legal representatives can be expensive
- add to delay of getting cases to trial
plea negotiations
pre-trial discussions between the prosecution and the accused, aimed at resolving the case by agreeing on an outcome
outcomes of plea negotiations
- the accused pleads guilty to fewer charges
- the accused pleads guilty to a charge with agreements made about the facts of the case
- the accused pleads guilty to a lesser charge
plea negotiations strengths
- save the cost of a trial or hearing
- help with the prompt determination of criminal cases
- accused may receive a reduced sentence
plea negotiations weaknesses
- community/victims may feel the negotiations don’t do justice
- self-represented accused may feel pressured to take a deal
- may lead to advantages/disadvantages if the case proceeds to trial
sentence indications
statements made by a judge to an accused about the sentence they could face if they plead guilty to an offence
new reforms to sentence indications
- must take place before a trial commences
- no prosecutor consent needed
- can be given multiple times
roles of the judge
- managing the trial
- deciding on the admissibility of evidence
- attending to jury matters
- giving directions to the jury
- handing down a sentence
roles of the jury
- take part in deliberations
- consider the elements of the crime
- deliver a verdict
purposes of sanctions
- rehabilitation
- punishment
- deterrence
- denunciation
- protection
the koori court 2020 expansion
f
-emphasises koori court importance
-sentence is still handed down by the judge
-not well enough established
a
-enables greater access to the koori court system
-does not address other issues such as access to information
e
-addresses the disadvantage faced by Indigenous australians
-sentencing only court, not available to everybody
victim support dog program 2019 reform
f
-intended to help see witnesses and victims deliver their evidence in a calm way
-jurors do not see the dog and so do not get influenced by their presence
a
-enable greater access to vulnerable witnesses
-witnesses may be more prepared to give evidence
e
-measures taken to make sure there is no inequality suffered
-seeks to provide assistance to vulnerable witnesses who are more at risk of suffering secondary trauma