1. Natural Law Flashcards
Aquinas - dates
1225-74
Telos definition
purpose
* Aristole said somethings good if it achieved this - aim for eudiamonia.
* God should be ultimate end of human life.
Aristole - key beliefs
- thought moral acts come from free raional beings - have to be free to make genuine decisons and use reason.
- God should be ultimate end of human lide.
- Thought people need help from God in order to direct motives and actions, to ensure the right thing is done for the right reasons.
4 tiers of law
- Eternal - God’s reason
- Divine - Commandments, bible
- Natural - Reason
- Human - Law’s
Primary precepts
- Preserve innocent life
- Orderly society
- Worship God
- Educate
- Reproduction
Secondary precepts
Derived from primary and illustrate practical application.
e.g. preserve life = no murder or abortion.
Real goods
In accordance to primary precepts and help further human florishment + Gods wishes for humanity.
Apparent goods
Things/actions which tempt up because they seem enjoyable but don’t further human florishment aim.
Natural/cardinal values =
prudence, temperanc, fortitude, justice.
In bible = faith, hope, love
Doctrine of double effect
Aquinas believed a single action had two effects.
that if doing something morally good has a morally bad side-effect, it’s ethically OK to do it providing the bad side-effect wasn’t intended
e.g. euthanasia = intention to relieve pain
Strengths
- application varries widely - allows for considerations of different circumstances.
- offers clarity + consistancy in answers.
- way of viewing world = absolute, applies to all times and cultures = universal - appealing.
- Combines religion with reason - allows exercise of autonomy.
- Arguanly easy to conclude - clear cut rules, can’t argue both sides.
Weaknesses
- Varies widely - not always a clear option.
- Aquinas’ version = presopposes belief in God, not everyone has.
- Understanding of what is vs isn’t natural isnt always accurate e.g. homosexuality.
- World has widely changed since Aquinas’ time, some application sare innappropriate for modern day e.g. contraception.