1 - Law and Legal Systems Flashcards
What are the two classifications of law?
Public Law
Private Law
What is public law? What sub-classifications does it include?
Law surrounding the legal structure of the State, relationships between the State and members of the community, and relationships between States.
It includes constitutional law, administrative law, and criminal law
What is constitutional law? What bodies does it apply to?
Law that governs the structure of the main institutions of government, their relationships between each other, and that of central and local government. It also covers the making of treaties and agreements with foreign states. In the UK it covers the monarchy, MPs, government ministers, the Judiciary, the Civil Service, and the Armed Forces
What is administrative law? What are some examples of areas it covers?
Law around the legal relationship between citizens and the various agencies of government. Examples are taxation, compulsory land purchase, local powers over highways, health, education, and various trade licenses
What is criminal law?
Law which governs and controls behaviours that may harm or threaten the peace and stability of the community
What is private law?
Law which governs the relationships between individuals (including businesses and other organisations)
What are the main branches of private law? Which are most important for insurance?
- The law of contract
- The law of torts
- The law of trusts
- The law of property
- The law of succession
- Family law
The most important for insurance are the law of contract and the law of torts
What are some of the main distinguishing features of English law?
Age and continuity Little codification Judge made law Independence of the judiciary Adversarial system No written constitution Rule of law
What is meant by the “age and continuity” of English law?
The law has developed without interruption for over 900 years. Some cases and statutes are over 500 years old and still relevant today
What is meant for when it is said that English law has “little codification”?
Codification is when a collection of laws on a particular subject are reduced to a single written code.
This occurred in some parts of English law (mainly criminal but also civil law including partnerships, sale goods, bills of exchange, and marine insurance) but largely it has not
What is meant by “judge made law”?
Binding precedent causes the decisions of judges to become part of the law and allows the law to develop
This differs from some countries where judges exist solely to interpret and apply the law
What is meant by the term “independence of the judiciary”?
English judges are largely free from political control and are separate from the government
How are judges appointed? How are they removed?
They are appointed by, or on the advice of, the Lord Chancellor or the Prime Minister
Senior judges can be removed only by a motion approved by both Houses of Parliament
Junior judges can only be removed by the Lord Chancellor on grounds of incapacity or misbehaviour
English law is an “adversarial system”. What does this mean and how does it differ from Roman law?
An adversarial system means the case is a contest between two sides - the plaintiff and defendant in a civil case, or the prosecution and defence in a criminal case. The court remains neutral and gives judgement only.
Roman law follows an inquisitorial system in which the court does not remain neutral but plays an active part in finding the truth. This is used in England only in the Coroners’ Courts
What are the consequences of English law having no written constitution?
A constitution defines the rights and freedoms of citizens. Since English law does not have one, there is simply the freedom to do anything which is not prohibited
How does the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights impact English law? How was it implemented in the UK?
By the Human Right Act 1998. It recognises certain human rights and allows for grievances to be taken to the European Court of Human Rights. It does not mean that the government is under a legal obligation to protect these rights and a statute breaching them would not invalidate the law. It simply requires that when legislation is presented to parliament there must be a declaration of compatibility. The courts should interpret statutes as compatible with the Human Rights Act where possible, and where not issue a declaration of incompatibility, which again does not invalidate the law or force the government to change it
What is the “rule of law”?
- The powers exercised by politicians and officials must have a proper foundation and come from authority given to them under law
- The law should be reasonably certain and predictable
- People should be treated equally
- No one should be punished or deprived of their property, status, or rights unless given a fair impartial hearing
- Everyone should have a right of access to the courts to defend their freedoms and liberties
Generally speaking when did English law begin to develop?
1066
What happened in 1066?
Following the Norman conquest they established a strong central government and uniform courts. A central royal court was established and travelling judges sent out to check on local administrations. They sought to apply the same rules everywhere. Local variations in law slowly disappeared and a uniform body of law emerged
What was the Court of Chancery? When was it established?
A court presided over by the Lord Chancellor, who was a churchman and spiritual advisor to the King, to hear cases concerning equity. More concerned with ensuring that individuals met moral obligations than the law itself. Established 1474
What was held in the Earl of Oxford’s case (1616)?
Is there was a conflict between common law and equity, then equity should prevail.
The reason given is that is impossible to make laws that can cover every possible action
What is meant by “equity”?
Literally meaning fairness, it is the body of rules and remedies dealt with in the Court of Chancery, which during the 1600s became distinct from common law and operated as a separate system under a different court
What were the Judicature Acts 1873-75?
Combined the common law courts and the Court of Chancery into a single system, at the time called the Supreme Court of Judicature. Now called the Senior Courts of England and Wales. Allowed common law and equity to be applied in the same court but equity still took precedent over common law
What are some examples of principles and remedies today that have come from the system of equity?
The law of trusts
Specific performance
Injunction
Promissory estoppel
What are the two main reasons that the law should develop over time?
- Social changes
2. Technological changes
What are the sources of law?
The main sources are legislation and judicial precedent
Minor sources are local custom and legal books/treatises
What does parliament consist of?
- The House of Commons
- The House of Lords
- The Monarch (as a formality only)
What is parliamentary delegation?
Parliament may transfer its law making powers to lesser bodies such as government ministries and local authorities
What form does parliamentary legislation make?
Acts of Parliament or Statutes
What actions may parliament take?
As the supreme law making body there is, in theory, no limit to their law making powers. They may:
- Create entirely new law
- Override existing law
- Modify or extend existing common law or equity
- Repeal or modify existing statute law
What is a green paper?
A paper published by the government inviting responses from interested parties on a proposed change to the law
What is a white paper?
A paper published by the government giving advance notice of a proposed change in law. More formal and definite than a green paper
What are the two types of parliamentary bills?
- Public Acts
2. Private Acts
What is a Public Act of Parliament?
Sets out laws affecting the whole community
What is a private act of Parliament?
Benefits a certain individual, organisation or group. For example a local authority seeking the power to make a compulsory purchase
What is an example of a private act that had a large impact on insurance?
Lloyd’s Act 1982
Established the Council of Lloyd’s
Who can introduce bills to parliament?
- The government
- Private members bills (although little to no chance of succeeding without government support since they control the timetable)
What stages must a bill pass in the House of Commons?
- First Reading
- Second Reading
- Committee Stage
- Report Stage
- Third Reading
What happens once a bill has passed all stages of the House of Commons?
It is passed to the Lords where it undergoes a similar process. They cannot completely reject a Public Bill and can only delay it’s progress and suggest amendments
After the Lords it receives Royal Assent from the monarch as a formality. Unless otherwise stated, it immediately becomes law
What happens if a public bill does not complete all stages in a single session of parliament?
The progress of the bill lapses when parliament is dissolved and it must start over again in the next session. This does not apply to private bills
What happens at the first reading of a bill?
The Clerk of the House reads the title of the bill to inform MPs of its existence. It is then printed and publishes. This is largely a formality
What happens at the second reading of a bill?
Generally it is referred to a Standing Second Reading Committee which recommends whether a bill should be read a second time. This is to save parliaments time and applies to all private bills and to public bills unless 20 MPs object
At second reading the house debates the bill and votes on whether it should proceed
What happens at the committee stage of a bill?
It is discussed in detail by a Standing Committee, made up of 20-30 MPs chosen to reflect the political makeup of the Commons. Amendments may be proposed and voted upon.
Bills of particular importance (eg the budget) are debated in a Committee of the Whole House
What happens at the report stage of a bill?
Amendments made in the Committee Stage are read to the house. They may be debated and in some cases referred back to the committee
What happens at the third reading stage of a bill?
There is a final debate in the house. Amendments could be made but generally they are only minor at this late stage. A vote is taken on whether to pass the bill to the Lords
What is a Consolidating Act?
Repeals all previous legislation on a particular subject and re-enacts it by bringing it all together under one act. Designed to tidy up the law. An example is the Road Traffic Act 1988
What is a Codifying Act?
Both consolidates previous legislation and includes principles from case law. In effect all the law on a subject, both statute and case law, is brought together in one single code. Mostly used for business law eg Bills of Exchange Act 1882, Partnership Act 1980, Sale of Goods Act 1979, and Marine Insurance Act 1906