1. formation of contracts Flashcards
common law vs. UCC
UCC – goods
Common law — others (services/real estate)
mixed contract: 1. all or nothing — except: divisible contract 2. predominant purpose
offer/acceptance is governed by ––– test
objective [words/conduct (implied-in-fact contract)]
how specific should the offer be?
common law: all essential terms
UCC: quantity [price is not essential]
[two step: goods?–UCC/common law–essential term?]
requirements contract vs. output contract
requirements contract: the buyer promise to buy all his demand from the seller during the period
output contract: the seller promise to sell all his production to the buyer during the period
both have quantity [as a formula]
invitations to deal vs. offer
a valid offer must create the power of acceptance in the offeree
advertisement is an invitation to deal, unless
- reward advertisement
- very specific and leave nothing for negotiation.
missing term vs. vague term
- missing term:
- common law: if parties have intent to form a contract, the court may supply a reasonable term
- UCC:
- gap filling: reasonable time, delivery at the seller’s place of business
- except: subject matter and quantity.
- vague terms: no presumption that the parties intend to form a contract
bilateral v. unilateral
bilateral: a return promise is requested
unilateral: an act is requested
termination of offer
- revoke by communication: effective upon receipt
- constructive revocation: offeree knew the offeror had taken an action that is absolutely inconsistent [house vs. book (fungible)] with a continuing ability to contact
- reject: effective upon receipt
- counter offer [vs. counter inquiry]
- death or mental incapacity of offeror before acceptance is effective [vs. death after formation]
- a reasonable period or a period specified by the offer [revival: give a same offer again when the old one lapsed] (from the time the offer is received - not sent) (if there is a delay in transmittal, expires when it would have been expired had there been no delay)
- destruction or illegality
撤回/拒绝/不一致,死了傻了/过期了,毁了违法/新要约
revocation of general offers
- general offer: made to a large number of people
- the revocation must be at the same level of publicity [regardless of actual knowledge]
irrevocable offer
- option: an independent promise to keep an offer open that the offeree has given separate consideration for
- UCC firm offer: (1) merchant, (2) writing + signed by the offeror + explicit promise to not revoke, (3) time period: as stated in the offer or a reasonable period — < 90 days
- unilateral contract + offeree has begun performance [the right but not the obligation to finish]
- detrimental reliance: reasonably foreseeable
unilateral v. bilateral
bilateral: acceptance = promise to perform / starting performance (obligation to complete)
unilateral: acceptance = complete performance (no obligation to complete)
whether the offer is unilateral or bilateral, is decided by the offeror
when there is ambiguity, may accept by either. (“please ship me two books.”)
means of acceptance
decided by offeror
if no specific instruction, any reasonable manner — used by the offeror, customarily in the industry, in prior transactions between the parties
acceptance by silence
- unilateral reward offer
- unilateral offer in which the parties are geographically close enough so that the offeror can see the performance occurred
- past history
- the offer says that acceptance must come by silence and the offeree intends to accept the offer by silence
shipment of nonconforming goods
acceptance + breach
but if the offeree [seller] seasonably notifies the buyer that the nonconforming goods are tendered as accommodation, then as counteroffer.
mailbox rule
acceptance by mail is effective when the mail is sent.
does not apply to
- other communications [revocations, rejections, counter offers] are effective upon receipt
- options and other irrevocable offers that requires the acceptance to be received before expiration of the offer
3.
- rejection following acceptance
- acceptance following rejection
- rejection following acceptance: acceptance shall control, unless the offeror detrimentally relied on the rejection.
- acceptance following rejection: first one received by the offeror [come into possession, not actually read the letter]
notice of acceptance
- bilateral contract: required [regardless by return promise or by beginning performance]
- unilateral contract: not required, unless he has reason to know the offeror would not learn of performance within a reasonable time, or the offer requires notice —- if notice is required but not given, the offeror’s duty is discharged unless
- the offeree has exercised reasonable diligence to notify
- the offeror has learnt about the performance within a reasonable time; or
- the offer indicates that notice of acceptance is not required