1 Flashcards
3 domains of public health
- health promotion - eg. inequality/housing
- health protection - eg. infectious disease prevention
- improving services - eg. audits/evaluation/efficiency
sociological perspectives on needs (Bradshaw’s needs)
- Felt need - individual perceptions of variation from normal health
- Expressed need - individual seeks help to overcome variation in normal health (demand)
- Normative need - professional defines intervention appropriate for the expressed need
- Comparative need - comparison between severity, range of interventions and cost
advantages of epidemiological approach to health needs assessment
- uses existing data
- provides data on disease incidence/mortality/morbidity
- can judge services on results over time
disadvantages of epidemiological approach to health needs assessment
- variable quality of data
- data collected may not be appropriate
- does not consider felt needs/experiences of those affected
cohort study
- Longitudinal study in similar groups but with different risk factors/treatments.
- Follows up over time
advantages of cohort study
- follow up
- identify risk factors
- confounders identified prospectively
disadvantages of cohort study
- large sample size required
- people drop out
- impractical for rare conditions
- expensive
case control study
- Observational study looking at cause of a disease
- Compares similar participants with disease and controls without
- Looks retrospectively for exposure/cause
advantages of case control study
- fast
- good for rare outcomes
disadvantages of case control study
- hard to find well-matched controls
- prone to selection bias
- prone to information bias
cross sectional study
- Observational study collecting data from a population and a specific point in time
- A snapshot of a group
advantages of cross sectional study
- Large sample size
- Provides data on prevalence of risk factors and disease
- Fast
- Repeated studies show changes over time
disadvantages of cross sectional study
- Risk of reverse causality – which came first?
- Less likely to include those who recover quickly or short recovery
- Not useful for rare outcomes
randomised controlled trial
similar participants randomly allocated to intervention or control group to study effect of intervention
disadvantages of RCTs
- High group drop out rate
- Ethical issues
- Time consuming and expensive
number needed to treat
1/attributable risk(aka risk difference)
what can association be due to?
- Bias
- Chance
- Confounding
- Reverse Causality
- True association
definition of bias
A systematic error that results in a deviation from the true effect of an exposure on an outcome
Bradford Hill causality criteria
1) temporality = exposure occurs before outcome
2) dose response = more exposure = inc risk of outcome
3) strength = stronger association (relative risk) = less chance due to something else
4) reversibility = take away exposure = reduces risk of outcome
5) consistency = pattern seen in different study types and different backgrounds/communities (reproducible)
6) plausibility = existence of a mechanism to explain cause and effect
7) coherence = consistency with other info
8) analogy = similarity with other cause/effect relationships
9) specificity = relationship is specific to outcome of interest
stages of planning cycle for health services
1) needs assessment
2) planning
3) implementation
4) evaluation
define a need
- the ability to benefit from an intervention
advantages of comparative approach
- take 2 or more different areas and compare their different services and their provision, utilisation, success, users background, etc.
- fast and cheap to do
- with limited resources, can decide what to continue or change
disadvantages of comparative approach
- May not yield what the most appropriate level
e.g. of provision or utilisation should be - Data may not be available
- Data may be of variable quality
- May be difficult to find a comparable
population
advantage of corporate approach
- listen to opinions of everyone involved, see where most need is
- suggestions that may not have been considered
- compromises made
disadvantages of corporate approach
- May be difficult to distinguish need from demand - Groups may have vested interests - May be influenced by political agendas - Dominant personalities may have undue influence
determinants of health
- Genes
- Environment
>Physical environment
>Socioeconomic environment - Lifestyle
- Health care
examining health equity - take into account…
- supply of health care
- access to health care
- utilisation of health care
- health care outcomes
- health status
- resource allocation
- wider determinants of health
primary prevention definition
actions to reduce the incidence of disease and health problems within the population
either through:
- universal measures that reduce lifestyle risks and their causes
- targeting high-risk groups