03 - Mediation Flashcards
Mediation Styles
Facilitative
Evaluative
Facilitative
WHAT
Focus = Interests; Needs; NO Opinion Mediator = Explore (Options); Formulate (DOC)
Evaluative
WHAT
Focus = Legal Merits; Opinion Mediator = Assessment NOT = Determination; Binding
Evaluative
Requirements MUST
Joint Request
Agreement = Both Parties; Mediator
Lawyer Preparation
Considerations
Objectives Analysis Evaluation Costs Review Arguments Value of Trial Clarification Stage of Proceedings
Mediation Preparation
Considerations
Mediation Agreement Pre-mediation Meeting Documents Attendees Multi Party Dispute
Mediation Agreement
WHAT
Enforceable Contract = Parties; Mediator
Signed
Mediation Agreement
Clauses
Parties Mediator Timetable Venue Procedure Issues Information = Without Prejudice Documents Authority Settlement = Non Binding Costs
Mediation Agreement
Authority TYPES
Subject to Authorisation
Direct = Disclose; Figures; Negotiation; Settlement
Venue
Requirements
Neutral Location
Three Rooms
Working Hours
Cost
Mediation Preparation
Documents
Core Bundle
Confidential Bundle
Core Bundle
Contents
Position Statement Supporting Documents Correspondence Case Management Orders Chronology Dramatis Personae
Supporting Documents
WHAT
Contract
Witness Statement
Expert Report
Confidential Bundle
Contents
Objectives
Legal Opinion
Offers AND Concessions
Position Statements
Purpose
Informal Document
Brief = Mediator; Other Party
Position Statements
Contents
Without Prejudice Parties Background Procedural History Matters = Agreed; Disputed Issues = Legal; Factual Evaluation = Evidence; Strength; Weakness Statement = Remedy; Reason
Position Statements
WHEN Required
Agreement
14 days < Mediation
Mediation Preparation
Attendees
Client Representative Lawyer Witness of Fact Expert
Attendees
Expert WHEN
Technical
Individual OR Joint
Multi Party Dispute
Factors
Number = Sub-group; Categories
Management = Information; Time
Confidentiality
Funding
Multi Party Dispute
MUST
Identify Groups
Timetable AND Order of Issues
Disclosure
Mediation Stages
Four
- Opening
- Exploration
- Negotiation
- Closing OR Settlement
Opening Stage
Topics
Mediator Introduction Settlement Opening Statements Witness AND Expert Mediator Closing
Mediator Introduction
Contents
Profession
Experience
Role = Neutral; F or E
Information = Confidential; Without Prejudice
Mediator Introduction
Settlement
Authority
Voluntary
Non Binding
Opening Statements
Contents
Refer = Position Statement
Witness AND Expert
WHAT
Summary of Evidence
Questions = Mediator; Lawyer
NOT XIC or XX
Mediator Closing
Contents
Summary = Matters; Issues; Evaluation; Remedies
Next Stages = Exploration; Negotiation
Exploration Stage
Purpose Closed Meetings
Analysis = Issues2 Evaluation = Evidence; Figures; Legal Merits; Success Consideration = Arguments; Position; Proposals
Exploration Stage
Purpose Open Meetings
Examine NEW Issues
Exchange = Information
Closed Meetings
Mediator Role
Probe Issues
Reality Check
Settlement Options = Creative; Court NOT Order
Negotiation Stage
Caucuses STEPS
Order = List of Issues
Propose (DOC)
Consider (DOC)
Negotiation
Mediator Role
Shuttle Diplomat OR Broker
Communicate = Offers; Concessions
Reframe = Demands
Negotiation
Deadlock - Mediator Role
Re-assess = Case
Re-consider = Arguments; Position; Proposals
Evaluative Opinion
Negotiation
Deadlock - Options
Adjourn
Alternative = Expert Determination
Litigation
Closing Stage
Settlement - Mediator Role
Draft = Memorandum of Agreed Terms
Record = Agreed Issues; Settlement
MUST Signed
Closing Stage
NO Settlement - Mediator Role
Statement = Adjourned OR Concluded Record = Reasons; Agreed Issues; Suggestions
Mediator
Selection Method
ADR Provider
Direct
Recommendation = Institute; Trade
Mediator
Selection Factors
Mediation Style = F or E Neutral Expertise = Profession Experience Accreditation Cost
Mediator
Accreditation Benefits
Code of Conduct
Complaints Procedure
Training
Indemnity Insurance
Mediator Role
Neutral
Structure Process
Assist Presentation
Intermediary
Mediator
Intermediary
Defuse Conflict
Reframe = Demands
Communicate = Offers; Concessions
Assist Evaluation = Strength; Weakness
Mediator
Role Function
Agreement
NOT Determination
Mediator
Claim Against WHEN
Breach Duty
Reasonable Care AND Skill
Improper Conduct
Mediator
Claim Result
Sue for Damages
Discipline ARD Provider
NOTE Exclusion Clause
Advocate Role
Advocate
Advice
Assist Mediator
Drafting
Advocate Role
Advocacy
Opening Statement
Advocate Role
Style
Non Adversarial
Purpose = Settlement; NOT Win
Advocate Role
Advisory
Manage Expectations
Understands = Procedure; Agreement; Settlement
Legal Position = Analysis; Evaluation
Strategy = DOC
Advocate Role
WITH Mediator
Persuade = Strength; Weakness Assist = DOC
Advocate Role
Drafting
Settlement = Draft Agreement
NO Settlement = Reasons; Agreed Issues; Suggestions
Confidentiality
Protected Information
Disclosed Information
Mediation Process
NOT Mediation Occurred
Confidentiality
NOT Protected
Enforce Binding Agreement = Terms; Settlement Concluded
Confidentiality
Enforcement
Court Order = Injunction
International Mediation
Advantages
National Experts
Neutral Jurisdiction
International Mediation
Disadvantages
Cultural Differences
Time
Cost
EU Directive in UK
Implementation
Cross-Border Mediation (EU Directive) Regulations 2011
EU Directive
Provisions
Mediation Recourse Mediator Training Confidential Enforceable Limitation Period NOT Expire
International Mediation
Enforcement CPR
CPR 78.24
Mediation Settlement Enforcement Order (MSEO)
International Mediation
Enforcement Procedure
Part 23 Procedure = Proceedings Issued
Part 8 Procedure = Proceedings NOT Issued
International Mediation
Enforcement Requirements
Settlement Agreement
Consent ALL Parties
Currency Conversion Certificate
International Mediation
Failure Consent
Judgement
Court Order = Award Enforceable
International Mediation
Enforcement Result
NO Hearing
Court Order = Award Enforceable
International Mediation
Limitation Act 1980
Suspend Limitation Period
IF Expired = Extends Period 8 weeks
NO Limit of Extensions
Mediation
Required Regulation
Independent Body
Professional Standards
Mediation
Independent Body
Code of Conduct
Complaint Procedure
Mediation
Professional Standards
Uniformity = Training; Accreditation
Indemnity Insurance
Civil Mediation Council (CMC)
WHO
Independent Body
Recognised Authority
Represent = Providers
Promote = ADR; Standards; Best Practice
Civil Mediation Council (CMC)
Schemes
Provider Accreditation Scheme
Individual Membership Registration Scheme
Provider Accreditation Scheme
Accreditation
Met Standards
Met Requirements
Insurance
Paid Fees
Provider Accreditation Scheme
Requirements
EU Model Code of Conduct
Complaints Procedure
6 Member Panel
Provider Accreditation Scheme
Member Panel Requirements
Assessed Training Course 12 months Experience Feedback Logbook CPD = Professional Development Indemnity Insurance
Individual Membership Registration Scheme
WHAT
Registration
NOT Accreditation
Individual Membership Registration Scheme
Conditions
Accredited Training Course = 40 hrs
CPD = Professional Development
Indemnity Insurance
Conciliation
WHAT
Assisted Negotiation AND Settlement
TYPES = Employment; Family
Conciliation
Employment WHO
ACAS (Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service)
Conciliation
Employment STEPS
1. ACAS Mandatory Contact Advice Limitation Period Suspended Agreement 2. Failure a. Early Conciliation Certificate b. Tribunal Hearing
Conciliation
Family WHO
CAFCASS (Child AND Family Court AND Support Service)
Conciliation
Family WHEN
Dispute Over Children
Contact
Residence
Conciliation
Family STEPS
- First Hearing Dispute Resolution Appointment
a. Agreement
b. Mediation - Failure
a. Court Hearing
Judicial Mediation Schemes
WHAT
Court Mediation
Mediator = Judge
Judicial Mediation Schemes
TYPES
Employment
Family
Technology AND Construction
Judicial Mediation Schemes
Employment STEPS
- CMD (Case Management Discussion)
a. Selection
b. Parties Consent - Judicial Mediation = Independent
- Failure
a. Tribunal Hearing
Judicial Mediation Schemes
Family STEPS
- Mandatory Meeting
a. MIAM (Mediation Information Assessment Meeting)
b. Agreement - Proceedings Issued
- First Hearing Dispute Resolution Appointment
a. Agreement
b. Judicial Mediation - Failure
a. Court Hearing
Judicial Mediation Schemes
Technology AND Construction STEPS
- Judicial Mediation
2. Court Hearing
Judicial Mediation Schemes
Advantage
Judge = Legal Expert
Written Assessment
Confidential
Cost
Judicial Mediation Schemes
Disadvantage
Judge = Evaluative NOT Facilitative Judge = NOT Neutral; MAY Influence
Court Mediation Schemes
WHAT
Court Mediation
Mediator = Independent (Court Employee; ADR Provider)
Court Mediation Schemes
TYPES
Small Claims
Court of Appeal
Civil Mediation Online Directory
Court Mediation Schemes
Advantages
Mediator = Independent Time = Arranged < > 2 weeks Cost = Fixed AND Low Fee
Small Claims Scheme
WHAT Claims
Claim Value = < £10k
NOT RTA
NOT PI
NOT Housing
Small Claims Scheme
STEPS
Referral IF Agree
Mediation = Free; Telephone
Mediator = HMCTS Employee
Small Claims Scheme
IF Success
Proceedings AUTO Stayed
Permission = Discontinue; Dismiss; Judgement
Small Claims Scheme
IF NO Success
Proceedings Continued
Directions Questionnaire
Hearing < 4 weeks
Court of Appeal Scheme
STEPS
Referral = Parties OR Court Mediation = 3 months > Referral
Court of Appeal Scheme
Mediator WHO
Selected from CAMS Panel
‘Court of Appeal Mediation Service’
Training Provided
Court of Appeal Scheme
Cost
£850+VAT per Party
PLUS Venue
Civil Mediation Online Directory
Operator
Ministry of Justice
Civil Mediation Online Directory
Purpose
Low Cost Mediation IF Coupon
Civil Mediation Online Directory
Cost
£50+VAT = < £5k £300+VAT = £5-15k £450+VAT = £15-50k Negotiation = £50k+