Week 10 Flashcards
Qualitative Research Methods (Part 2)
What are the four main types of knowledge syntheses in clinical research?
Narrative reviews, scoping reviews, systematic reviews, and meta-analyses.
What does qualitative data analysis involve?
A broad range of processes and procedures for working with a large body of qualitative data to develop an understanding of people and situations under investigation.
What philosophical approach is qualitative data analysis usually based on?
An interpretive philosophy that guides the examination of data, focusing on meaning, content, and symbolism.
What is the main purpose of a narrative review?
To provide a thorough and critical overview of previously published research on a given topic.
What are other names for a narrative review?
Traditional literature review or umbrella review.
What are three advantages of narrative reviews?
Help identify key themes, patterns, and trends in studies concerning a topic.
Help identify knowledge gaps.
Assist with setting priorities for future research.
What is a major limitation of narrative reviews compared to systematic reviews?
They are less structured and rigorous.
Why might narrative reviews be prone to selection bias?
They may favor certain studies at the expense of others.
What issue arises from the lack of a formal protocol in narrative reviews?
They do not specify inclusion/exclusion criteria, selection of final studies, or analysis methods.
What is the primary purpose of scoping reviews?
To map the volume, characteristics, and breadth (scope) of literature on a given topic.
What key aspects do scoping reviews focus on?
Identifying gaps, conceptual boundaries, working definitions, and mapping evidence.
What types of information can scoping reviews summarize?
Evidence maps, policy maps, concept maps, and future research scope.
What is one reason researchers conduct scoping reviews?
To identify the types of evidence on a given topic, including peer-reviewed publications, grey literature, and consensus statements.
How do scoping reviews help with understanding literature?
They clarify key terms and concepts in the literature.
What aspect of research methods can scoping reviews examine?
How research is conducted on a topic, such as observational vs. experimental designs or quantitative vs. qualitative approaches.
How do scoping reviews assist in identifying future research needs?
By identifying knowledge gaps in the existing literature.
What do scoping reviews help determine regarding systematic reviews?
Whether a more rigorous systematic review is appropriate and feasible.
What is the purpose of a systematic review?
To provide a structured critical assessment of the literature addressing a well-defined, specific question.
What is the main goal of a systematic review?
To provide the best possible answers or conclusions based on the available evidence.
How is literature for systematic reviews selected?
Using specific inclusion and exclusion criteria based on strict protocols.
How many researchers are typically required to carry out a systematic review?
At least two researchers, ideally three in case a tie-breaking vote is needed.
Why is having multiple researchers important in systematic reviews?
To resolve areas of disagreement and ensure objectivity.
How long does a systematic review typically take to complete?
Usually 6–18 months.
How is a meta-analysis different from a systematic review?
While often used as a synonym for systematic reviews, a meta-analysis is a distinct knowledge product that combines study results statistically.
What does a meta-analysis aim to achieve?
It generates key measures regarding associations or cause-and-effect relationships across multiple studies on a topic.
What is a key feature of a meta-analysis?
It goes beyond summarizing studies to perform statistical analyses of the combined results.
What does positivism/empiricism suggest about reality?
A single reality exists that can be counted or measured.
What is the central idea of critical realism?
“Reality” exists, but our perception of it is shaped by our experiences.
How does constructivism view reality?
Reality is a human and social construction.
What do critical theories (e.g., anti-racism, class, LGBTQ, feminist) propose about reality?
Reality is shaped by oppression, power, and identity struggles.
What is the first key point of focus in analyzing qualitative data?
The primary message content.
What aspect of the speaker is analyzed in qualitative data?
The attitude of the speaker regarding the content.