Red Book Workshop Flashcards
What does the Red Book state about sustainability and environmental matters?
The 2022 Global Red Book emphasizes sustainability and ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) issues in VPS 2, VPS 3, VPGA 2, and VPGA 8. Valuers must consider how environmental risks, health impacts, and corporate responsibility affect the asset’s long-term value.
What is ESG?
ESG stands for Environmental, Social, and Governance, three pillars for assessing sustainability and ethical practices in organizations, covering environmental impact, social responsibility, and governance practices.
What are natural environmental constraints?
Natural environmental constraints are physical factors like flooding, heat waves, wildfires, and storms that influence property values due to climate or land use.
What are non-natural environmental constraints?
Non-natural environmental constraints include regulatory factors such as energy efficiency standards, carbon emission regulations, and environmental policies affecting property values.
What does PS 1 address?
PS 1 addresses the compliance framework for valuations, ensuring they adhere to the Red Book and International Valuation Standards (IVS) for global consistency.
What does PS 1 say about VPS 1 to 5?
PS 1 establishes the framework, while VPS 1-5 outline the technical and performance standards for valuations. Exceptions apply in specific cases, such as statutory functions or expert testimony.
What does PS 2 cover and when does it apply?
PS 2 covers ethics, competency, objectivity, and disclosures for valuers, applying to all valuation services and ensuring independence, transparency, and disclosure of conflicts of interest.
What do each of VPS 1 to VPS 5 address?
VPS 1: Minimum Terms of Engagement, VPS 2: Inspections and Investigations, VPS 3: Valuation Reports, VPS 4: Bases of Value, Assumptions, and Special Assumptions, VPS 5: Valuation Approaches and Methods.
What is a basis of value?
A basis of value defines the fundamental assumptions about a transaction’s nature, the relationship between the parties, and the asset’s market exposure.
Examples in the Red Book?
Recognized bases include Market Value, Market Rent, Investment Value, Fair Value, Existing Use Value, and EUV (SH) for social housing.
Are any non-Red Book bases of value permissible?
Yes, statutory or regulatory authorities may require non-Red Book bases, such as Tenanted Market Value or Current Value for public sector assets.
What is a basis of value often coupled with?
A basis of value is typically coupled with assumptions or special assumptions that define the asset’s condition or status for valuation purposes.
What is Special Value?
Special Value is the additional value an asset holds for a special purchaser due to unique attributes unavailable to other buyers.
What is Marriage Value?
Marriage Value arises from combining two or more assets, creating a combined value greater than the sum of the individual parts.
Are they the same thing?
No, Special Value is unique to a buyer, while Marriage Value results from asset combination. Marriage Value may include Special Value if beneficial only to one buyer.
What are Assumptions?
Assumptions are factors reasonably accepted as fact in a valuation, limiting further investigation by the valuer.
Where do we state them?
Assumptions are stated in the Terms of Engagement and the valuation report.
When do we state them?
Assumptions must be agreed upon with the client in advance of the valuation report issuance.
What are Special Assumptions?
Special Assumptions differ from actual facts at the valuation date and may show how value changes under different circumstances.
Where do we state them?
Special Assumptions are expressly agreed upon in writing with the client and included in the valuation report.
When do we state them?
They are stated in the Terms of Engagement and the valuation report, used only when realistic, relevant, and valid for the valuation.
What do we mean by a ‘Projected Value’?
Projected Value refers to an asset’s estimated future value based on changing market conditions or development progress.
What steps are necessary if providing a Projected Value?
Steps include using realistic Special Assumptions, reporting separately from current valuations, highlighting uncertainty, and clearly stating that the value is speculative.
At a lease rent review, what Basis of Value do you use, and where do you find that basis?
Market Rent is the basis used, defined as the estimated lease amount based on current market conditions and agreed lease terms.
What is investment value or worth, and when would you apply it?
Investment Value is specific to the owner, reflecting the asset’s value based on its utility for individual investment or operational purposes.
What is Fair Value?
Fair Value is defined as the price to sell an asset or transfer a liability between market participants at the measurement date.
When would you use Fair Value as your basis of valuation?
Fair Value is used for financial reporting purposes, especially under IFRS 13, rather than transactional purposes.
What is the difference between Existing Use Value and Market Value for Existing Use?
Existing Use Value reflects the asset’s value in its current operational state, while Market Value for Existing Use includes potential alternative uses but is limited to current use.
When would you use each?
EUV is used for financial reporting for owner-occupied assets, while Market Value for Existing Use is applied in cases outside financial reporting.
What is the EUV (SH) basis of value?
EUV-SH (Existing Use Value for Social Housing) is used to value social housing based on the assumption that it will remain subject to social housing regulations.
When is it used?
EUV-SH is used when valuing social housing properties for financial statements, assuming they remain subject to regulatory constraints.
What does the Red Book say constitutes a written valuation?
According to PS 1 paragraph 1.3 of the 2020 Global Edition, a written valuation encompasses all forms of communication except those that are purely oral.
What does the Red Book say about oral valuations?
PS 1 paragraph 1.6:
• Where valuation advice is provided wholly orally, the principles outlined in the Red Book should still be observed as much as possible.
• Oral valuations do not negate the valuer’s responsibility or liability.
• Both oral and written advice are subject to the same criteria, particularly if the valuer is acting as an expert witness.