protections Flashcards
Custody
formal arrest or a situation where a reasonable person in the suspect’s position would believe their freedom has been deprived to a degree analogous with formal arrest.
Interrogation
questioning where a reasonable officer would anticipate the questions would likely result in an incriminating response.
the trigger for Miranda warning
custody + interrogation
Critical Stages for right to counsel
Includes the deliberate elicitation of statements (express or implied), a physical identification proceeding, the preliminary hearing, and trial.
right to counsel protections are only for
defendants!
right to counsel only applies to
defendants and in relation to the crime charged
waiver
all of these protections can be waived
• Fruit of the Poisonous Tree and Confessions
o If a statement is a “but for” consequence of a prior constitutional violation (normally, an arrest in violation of the Fourth Amendment), the statement may be inadmissible fruit of a poisonous tree unless the government can prove an exception, even if it complies with due process, Miranda, and the Sixth Amendment.
most common exception: attenuation
due process rule: identification
If the defendant can prove that an identification procedure used by the government was so unnecessarily suggestive that it created an irreparable risk of mistaken identification, the procedure violates due process and the ID is inadmissible.
due process test is reliability; requiring D to prove
that procedures used were unnecessary;
that they were arranged by the government;
that they were suggestive; and
that the suggestiveness results in an “irreparable risk” of an unreliable ID.
if a court supresses an out of court ID
in court id is not allowed
in-person line up ID violates 6th consequences
1- id per se invalid
2- unless the prosecution can prove by clear and convincing evidence that the in-court identification is independent from the inadmissible out-of-court identification.
grand jury
no miranda necessary to testify
bail hearing
considered defendant, but not part of 6th amendment
prejudice in right to speedy trials
anxiety;
oppressive pre-trial incarceration; and
degradation of evidence compromising the accuracy of the trial. (best)