PLP All Flashcards
O’May v City of London Real Property Co
Held that the terms of the current lease would be the starting point for the terms of the renewal lease. It is for the party who wishes to change the existing terms to justify the change by reference to changes of circumstances.
Corresponding date rule
6 months serve on 1 July = 1 Jan
If 31 Aug -> 31 Feb (feb obviously doesn’t have 31 days, so it would be the last day of the month)
From and including
10 years from and including 24 march, expires 23 march 2028
from
10 years from 25 march, means start date is 26th, which means expires on the 25
who can apply for court application?
either
Protecting court application
T lodge unilateral at Land Reg against L’s title (unreg land = pending land action)
Renewal lease terms/principles
parties agree otherwise the court will look to s32-54 of act to direct court as to new terms
Lambert v Woolworth
s19(2) LPA 1925
Improvements seen through the eyes of the Tenant. Thus, all improvements are alterations…
International Drilling
s19(1)(a) LTA 1927
Applies to qualified covenant relating to alienation
Upgrades Q to FQ and allows L to recover reasonable costs incurred.
Reasonable dealt within International drilling - grounds for refusal must be based on L and T relationship
s19(IA) applies to…?
Assignment only
s1 LTA 1988
Applies to ALL leases
Where a written applicaiton is made for L’s consent, L must respond in writing within a reasonable time (Dang Bang said this is 28 days).
NB: s1 does NOT upgrade a Q to FQ - it only applies to FQ covenants
Burden on L to prove refusal is unreasonable
s19(1)(a) cases
Law
of the four Ls with assignment
International Drilling
Moss Bros
Ashworth Fraser
International Drilling
Assignment
reason for refusal must pertain to actual agreement/L&T relationship and not frivolous factors e.g. not liking T
Moss Bros
Tenant mix policy = reasonable, policy stated to T and reasonable
Ashworth Fraser
L can refuse if anticipates will lead to a breach of convenant
Documents required for assignement of a lease
At least 3 (maybe more if L has imposed more conditions under Clause X)
License to Assign (entered into between L, T and A)
Deed of Assignment required between T and A
AGA (required by Clause X) entered into between L and T
NO NEW LEASE CREATED.
Recommendation Code 5
AGAs should NOT be required as a condition (unless proposed A is lower financial standing than T)
Registration of assignment
If registered - require register to change details of proprietorship
SDLT - may be charge if any premium is paid by assignee to T for lease within 30 days of completion
Law paragraph when doing the 4 Ls
for both assignment and alienation
Q: Clause X is upgraded by s19(1)(a) to FQ, this means L cannot withhold consent unreasonable.
International Drilling - reasons for refusal must pertain to agreement or L-T relationship, not frivolous
Moss bros: tenant mix policy is reasonable so long as stated and reasonable
Ashworth Fraser: can refuse if anticipates will lead to breach of covenant.
Crestford Ltd v Tesco
All preconditions have to be satisfied before L even has to consider giving consent.
Documentation for underletting
License to under let - parties to under let, L T and UT AND any guarantor of the under tenant
Under lease - executed by T and UT (refer to payment of L’s costs). Need to register if over 7 years,
NB term is always less than that of the superior lease, otherwise takes effect as an assignment.
Types of rent review
Stepped rent - rent will go up by a specific amount as set out in lease
Turnover rent - relative to turnover of Co leasing, %
Index Linked rent review - annual rent goes up by ref to agreed measure of inflation
open market rent - based on value of property and market rents of comparable property in same locality as the premises at the time of review
Market rents
based on value of property and market rents of comparable properties in same locality as the premises at time of review
- involves PERIOD revaluation of rent based on what rent would be if premises were re let afresh at date of review
- based on comparable
- unusual for them to be ‘upwards only’, stay same or up
- rent determined by valuer who looks to comparable and HYPOTHETICAL LEASE (and flexibility of ts terms).