Exam I Flashcards
What are some methodologies to study happiness? (list)
Surveys (including self-report)
Stress granules (when cells are under stress)
Observations (smiling, laughing)
Cross-sectional
Longitudinal
Experiments (but not really because of ethics)
Aggregated data and models
Quantitative measures (subjective happiness scale, purist questions, positive and negative affect schedule, Big Five Personality
Interviews (qualitative)
Journaling (qualitative)
Well-being
“a life that goes well for you”
well-being is a value, while happiness is a condition. What is good for us?
Happiness is more than just our state of mind (emotional state theory) - grounded in reality
What are the three theories from Haybron about Happiness?
- Emotional State theory - happiness as a positive emotional condition (a feeling)
- Hedonism - happiness as pleasure (a feeling)
- Life satisfaction theory - happiness as being satisfied with your life (a judgment)
Attunement
When you let your defenses down (tranquility/inner peace), arguably forms the core of happiness.
Anxiety, stress, insecurity can rob us of our ability to engage in the other dimensions.
Can be easy to ignore because it doesn’t command our attention like the other two.
Engagement
Is it worth investing much time and effort in your activities, or should we withdraw and disengage from them? Includes vitality (states of energy) and flow (when you are fully engaged in an activity)
Endorsements
The actual feeling of being happy; signifying that your life is positively good & the most familiar aspect of happiness. i.e. feelings of joy and sadness, success and failure
Three major dimensions of happiness (emotional state theory?)
- Attunement
- Engagement
- Endorsements
What are the two forms of engagement?
- vitality - states of energy
2. the notion of flow (when you are fully engaged in an activity - especially a challenging activity performed well)
Mood propensity
the tendency to experience certain moods and emotions rather than others
Hedonism
Happiness as pleasure (a feeling); the hedonic treadmill (we repeatedly return to our baseline level of happiness); Hedonists tend to define happiness as a positive balance of pleasant over unpleasant experiences
Davis NYT Article
Critiques productivity society & placing responsibility on individuals to be happy; happiness is politicized - why would a business want to push happiness? Productivity
Agarwal NYT Article
link between happiness and sustainability (shifting our perspectives so that happiness is linked to sustainability & equality)
Ehrenreich NYT Article
most happiness tests conflate happiness with life satisfaction
Lyubomirsky NYT Article
happy people are physically healthier (also a connection with the TED talk we watched last class) & happiness is achievable (but we shouldn’t be obsessed)
Examples of global attempts to measure happiness
HDI, Environmental Performance Index, OCED well-being, World Happiness Report, and ESRI
ESRI and World Happiness report - subject self-reported well-being
Some reports connected sustainability
Some measures focused on sustainability
Takeaway: there are many different measures of happiness – different countries had different rankings
Percentages of Happiness (& critique)
50% genetic
10% circumstance and environment
40% attitude
What about marginalized folks and social structures and inequities?
What are the limits of self-report measures?
They are very subjective! how people feel can change on a minute-to-minute basis. People may tend to overestimate. What if someone’s definition of a word is different? Also, survey length can deter people from answering questions/they get distracted)
Cross-sectional methodology
Acts as a snapshot of a population
Samples across age groups, genders, etc.
You don’t follow up with people
Longitudinal Studies
Example: the Harvard 75 year study
Checking in with the same population at a later date
Probably better than cross-sectional because you get to see change across the same population
Experiments
Super hard to do because what about the ethicality? You can’t assign a “happiness” condition easily/ethically
Decisions & benefit when using Aggregated Data & Models
Decisions: How much do you value different variables? Any form of modeling also involves weighing (importance)
What variables do you choose to look at? (access to water, women in government, etc.) (this can be difficult to collect data on)
Benefit: allow for comparing between countries
Types of quantitative measures
Subjective happiness scale - how happy are you on a scale of 1-7
Purist questions: yes/no
Positive and negative affect schedule: in this moment select all the words that describe your affect (strong, guilty, interested, hostile, distressed)
“The Big Five” Personality test (I think you did this for SHS Leila)
We do our best to counteract biases (but humans are complex, what can we say?)
Types of qualitative measures & the value
Observations (who is smiling on the street?)
less-structured interviews
I.e. What is your definition of happiness?
Have people journal and do a text analysis
(Can be valuable because it allows us to unpack complex dimensions of human experience)
Major Critique of Wiking’s Lykke
Focuses on European majority-white countries (and cites mostly white men)