Dom Rel Flashcards
Breach of Promise to Marry - TN
- 1 yr statute of limitations
- promise must be in writing OR proved by 2 disinterested witnesses
- not widely used today but still on the books
- party may seek redress for injury to reputation as well as reliance damages
Defenses to Breach of Promise to Marry
A. Ill health of P
B. Previous unchastity of P if D didn’t know
C. Existing marriage of either party at time of promise if P knew about previous marriage
D. Insanity, duress, etc.
Damages for Breach of Promise to Marry
- Compensation for financial loss
- Loss of reputation
- Mental suffering
- Punitive (if jury finds acts of D “willful and oppressive”)
- If D is over sixty, damages limited to P’s financial loss
Strict Scrutiny
Where gov. must show that the challenged classification serves a compelling state interest and the the classification is necessary to serve that interest, and that the statute is narrowly drawn to accomplish that end
Suspect classifications:
1. Race
2. National origin
3. Religion (either under Equal Protection or Establishment)
Middle-Tier Scrutiny
Gov. must show that the challenged classification serves an important state interest that the classification is at least substantially related to serving that interest.
Quasi-suspect classifications:
1. Gender
2. Illegitimacy
Minimum Scrutiny (rational basis test)
Gov. need only show that the challenged classification is rationally related to serving a legitimate state interest
Griswold v. Connecticut
Landmark case for idea of Right to privacy
- 1st Amend. freedom of association
- 3rd Amend. prohibiting quartering troops in a private home
- 4th Amend. protection against unreasonable searches and seizures
- 5th Amend. self incrimination, privacy of home against gov. intrusion
- 9th Amend. people have rights other than those in Constitution
2 Types of Marriage Requirements
- Mandatory
2. Directory
Mandatory Requirements
- Without following these, the ceremonial marriage is VOID ab initio
Directory Requirements
- Without following these, marriage is VOIDABLE
Void ab initio
- Bigamy
- Incest
- Interested parties can attack the validity of the marriage
- Validity may be attacked after death of a party
2 Steps
- Declare void or voidable
2. Declare valid/invalid
Incest
- Lineal ancestor or descendant
- Lineal ancestor of either parent
- Lineal descendant of husband or wife
- Lineal descendant of husband or wife of parent (stepparents, stepchildren, step siblings, daughter/son in law)
- Probably covers adopted children
Marriage is INVALID due to lack of capacity
Bigamy
in TN there is a strong but rebuttable by CLEAR and CONVINCING presumption in favor of last marriage
Marriage by Estoppel
- An equitable remedy where a court may, where there is a) and invalid marriage for whatever reason, but b) to declare that marriage invalid would result in unjust/inequitable result unless party receives relief
- avoids unfair result
- Cannot apply if both parties know about impediment
Enoch Arden
- If a party disappears for two years and is thought to be dead, and the other party remarries, the returning party insist on restoration of conjugal rights or dissolution of the marriage
- Must be filed within one year of return
Common Law Marriage
- 2 people must agree they are married
- Live together
- Present themselves as husband and wife
- Assumption of marital duties and obligations
- Permanent and exclusive of all others
- Recognized in only 9 states
Mensa et thoro
- Legal separation
- Grounds are the same as divorce
- Unless other party objects, a legal separation shall be granted
- Should plead in the alternative to divorce
- Court may award spousal support, visitation of children
- May even permanently divide marital property, making after acquired property separate property
- STILL married, adultery may create grounds for divorce
- If parties fail to reconcile after two years, Court may grant divorce
No fault divorce pros and cons
- Lessens fraud
- Lessens animosity
- Encourages cooperation
- Makes divorce easier and quicker
- Increased divorce rate
Irreconcilable differences
- Parties must reach agreement that court accepts on all issues
- Service and answer may be waived so long as matter is resolved within 180 days of signature on waiver
Grounds for divorce
- Legal separation 2 yrs
- Impotency
- Bigamy
- Adultery
- Desertion
- Felony conviction with confinement in pen
- Infamous crime conviction
- Attempt to kill spouse
- Refusal by one spouse to move to TN for 2 yrs
- Pregnancy upon marriage by another w/o knowledge of H
- Addict post-marriage
- Cruel/inhuman treatment
- Indignities
- Abandonment or kick out other with no support
- Separate residence
- Irreconcilable differences
Cruel and inhuman treatment
- the willful, persistent causing of unnecessary suffering, whether by realization or apprehension, whether of the mind or body, in such a way as to render cohabitation unsafe unendurable
- false accusations of adultery
- false charges of sexual abuse
- abnormal sex
- browbeating and bullying
- attentions to persons of the opposite sex
- swearing at your spouse
- failure to provide suitable home and clothing
- holding a gun to spouse
- notice to merchants not to extend credit to spouse
- Making threatening phone calls
No fault grounds for divorce
- Separation for more than 2 years
- if parties live apart and no minor children or
- even if minor children, if one of the general grounds for divorce exist and the parties remain separated 2 yrs after decree of legal separation - Irreconcilable differences
- must execute marital dissolution agreement
-
Defenses to adultery
- Recrimination, plaintiff is also guilty of adultery
- Condonation - Plaintiff learned of D’s adultery and continued relationship
- Connivance - plaintiff hired wife out for prostitution
Residence requirements
A divorce may be granted for any of the causes referenced in 36-4-101 if the acts complained of were committed while the plaintiff was a bona fide resident of this state or if the acts complained of were committed out of this state and the plaintiff resided out of the state at the time, if the plaintiff or the defendant has resided in this state 6 months next preceding the filing of the complaint
Venue
Suit may be filed
1) where D resides
2) where parties resided at time of separation, or
3) if D is non-resident, county of P’s residence
- Parties may agree to waive venue but court can veto that agreement
Automatic temporary injunctions
- Automatic injunction is in effect upon filing of a regular grounds divorce
- Injunction remains in effect until resolution of case or until suit is dissolved
- Parties restrained from:
1) Harassing/assaulting/threatening/abusing
2) making disparaging remarks to children or employers
3) relocating children more than 50 miles from marital home or outside state (unless moving party has well-founded fear of physical abuse)
Grandparent Rights
- Troxel
- Grandparents generally have no rights over the parent
- State may step in (parens patriae) to determine when health of child is in jeopardy
- Constitutional right to raise children free from overly invasive gov. interference
UCCJEA
- Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act
- Home State Jurisdiction- Priority to child’s home state or home state at some time in last 6 months
- Significant Contact Jurisdiction - child has no home state, another state may exercise jurisdiction if child has sufficient ties to that state
- Forum Non-Conveniens - when home state and significant connection state decline jurisdiction in favor of more appropriate state
- Vacuum jurisdiction - no appropriate jurisdiction, alternative court may exercise jurisdiction
- Emergency jurisdiction - temporary for when child has been abandoned or because child/sibling/parent has been threatened
Temporary order of enforcement
A court without jurisdiction may issue temporary order enforcing
1) visitation schedule made by court of another state or
2) visitation provisions of child custody determination of another state that does not provide for specific visitation schedule
Registration of foreign decrees
Child custody determination issued by court of another state may be registered in this state with or without a simultaneous request for enforcement, by sending to the appropriate court in this state
Enforcement
After court receives request to register the court shall:
1) file order as foreign judgment
2) serve notice on persons affected to allow them to contest registration
3) Notice must state that order is enforceable as an order from this state from day of registration
4) hearing must be requested if affected persons want to contest registration within 20 days
5) If no complaint within 20 days, order will be confirmed and preclude further contest